Recent Topics
governor stuck on carburetor?
by motor_oil_madman
34 minutes 41 seconds ago
BMW 3 series reliability?
by ford46guy
45 minutes 8 seconds ago
debris in drained oil, how bad is this? (pics)
by John_Dude
50 minutes 35 seconds ago
10W30 oil for Dodge Magnum SXT?
by Oldyellr
Today at 05:16 PM
Anyone here into drones?
by 55Test
Today at 05:00 PM
Gassing Up A Hybrid
by AirgunSavant
Today at 04:56 PM
O2 sensors needed for closed loop?
by 55Test
Today at 04:51 PM
zddp additives
by JDMiller
Today at 04:11 PM
Windshield Wipers | Hybrid vs Beam style
by lucas01230
Today at 04:08 PM
Talk to me about a...umm...errr...Glo
ck 19

by 2015_PSD
Today at 03:59 PM
Wiper blade refills Trico Exact fit vs. Toyota OEM
by jrvn
Today at 03:03 PM
2016 Honda CRV Blended oil
by Bubba1947
Today at 02:17 PM
Newest Members
Wally3626, lancelot50, arthur88boston, cbuck, lwralaVTC92
59218 Registered Users
Who's Online
84 registered (Analyzer, AnthemBassMan, 2015_PSD, 2009Edge, 901Memphis, AirgunSavant, 10 invisible), 1857 Guests and 11 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
59218 Members
66 Forums
255069 Topics
4190218 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG
Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Topic Options
#1581270 - 08/28/09 12:56 PM 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same bott
21Rouge Offline


Registered: 06/04/05
Posts: 1954
Loc: Vinegar Hill
The chronology:

I sent in a virgin sample to Blackstone for the generally highly regarded Petro Canada Supreme Synthetic (in this case its 0W30 entry). Looking at the numbers I was surprised by the calcium, phosphorus and zinc...all seemed low. Blackstone was kind enough to retest...the new numbers were similar.

I contacted Petro Canada and they requested I submit a sample to them. He did tell me, prior to testing my sample, that he expected, based upon batch analysis that Calcium would be around 2230, Phosphorus 780 and Zinc 870.

I have summarized the information below. (I have a full analysis for only Blackstone and Wearcheck)

All samples were taken from the *same* bottle of new unopened oil.
Code:
		Initial Blackstone	Retest of same sample (Blackstone)	In House Petro Canada Lab	Wearcheck Canada

Calcium		1214			1196					2250				2015

Phosphorus	422			430					780				694

Zinc		572			554					940				814


Edited by 21Rouge (08/28/09 12:56 PM)

Top
#1581272 - 08/28/09 12:58 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same bott [Re: 21Rouge]
ZZman Offline


Registered: 03/17/08
Posts: 4248
Loc: Michigan
Hmmm. very interesting.


Edited by ZZman (08/28/09 12:58 PM)
_________________________
2002 Buick Regal GS (3.8 Supercharged) PP, Pure 1 filter
2008 Sebring Hardtop convertible (2.7) PP, Pure 1 filter.
2006 Kawasaki Vulcan 900 LT

Top
#1581288 - 08/28/09 01:21 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same bott [Re: ZZman]
Trav Offline


Registered: 11/20/06
Posts: 14360
Loc: MA, Mittelfranken.de
Downright disturbing is what i call it.
People buy oil,switch brands,weights etc based on the numbers coming out of these labs.

I never got into doing UOA because i question the value if a UOA on a single run of a specific brand then doing another on the latest craze trying to compare the two.
Long term trends with the same product i would think may provide better results.

The way this looks it appears that some of these labs may be pulling numbers either from manufacturers spec sheets or out of their behind.
_________________________
ASE L1, Master. Deutsch Meisterbrief.

Top
#1581291 - 08/28/09 01:26 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same bott [Re: Trav]
pbm Offline


Registered: 04/19/04
Posts: 6518
Loc: New York
This tells me that my money is better spent changing my oil than analyzing it.

Top
#1581297 - 08/28/09 01:32 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same bott [Re: pbm]
Boomer Offline


Registered: 09/19/08
Posts: 1819
Loc: Pennsylvania
Amen. So when you look at these numbers from UOA, remeber that the standard deviations are apparently HUGE when looking at these numbers. It tells me that these numbers are virtually worthless.
_________________________
2013 VW Passat TDI SE, 36,800 miles
2014 VW Jetta TDI SportWagen 19,455 miles

Top
#1581300 - 08/28/09 01:39 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: Trav]
21Rouge Offline


Registered: 06/04/05
Posts: 1954
Loc: Vinegar Hill
Originally Posted By: Trav

The way this looks it appears that some of these labs may be pulling numbers either from manufacturers spec sheets


FWIW I purposely did not tell Wearcheck the brand or viscosity of oil.

Top
#1581302 - 08/28/09 01:47 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: Trav]
21Rouge Offline


Registered: 06/04/05
Posts: 1954
Loc: Vinegar Hill
Originally Posted By: Trav
Long term trends with the same product i would think may provide better results.




+1, and now with the caveat that one uses the same lab! smirk

Top
#1581303 - 08/28/09 01:50 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: 21Rouge]
Anies Offline


Registered: 01/29/09
Posts: 2804
Loc: NJ
I wonder if additive fallout(some falling to the bottom) would cause numbers like that. I myself am no chemist and not sure if calcium itself can fall out of suspension in oil.
_________________________
2012 Nissan Frontier SL V6 (mine)
2014 Ford Fusion SE w/Tech (wifey)
+Dealer Serviced

Top
#1581305 - 08/28/09 01:52 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: Anies]
21Rouge Offline


Registered: 06/04/05
Posts: 1954
Loc: Vinegar Hill
Originally Posted By: Anies
I wonder if additive fallout(some falling to the bottom) would cause numbers like that.


I promise I shook the bottle each time I drew a sample.

Top
#1581306 - 08/28/09 01:53 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: 21Rouge]
FZ1 Offline


Registered: 02/07/08
Posts: 4192
Loc: Texas
Now you know why I ain't doin' no UOAS.

Top
#1581307 - 08/28/09 01:54 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: 21Rouge]
Trav Offline


Registered: 11/20/06
Posts: 14360
Loc: MA, Mittelfranken.de


Quote:
and now with the caveat that one uses the same lab!


It would sure seem that way.

Did you inform Petro what the sample was beforehand?
The numbers seem real close to what he told you they would be,
Do you get the feeling they just tweaked the numbers and actually tested nothing?





Edited by Trav (08/28/09 01:55 PM)
_________________________
ASE L1, Master. Deutsch Meisterbrief.

Top
#1581314 - 08/28/09 01:58 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: Trav]
addyguy Offline


Registered: 09/08/05
Posts: 13975
Loc: Canada
Wearcheck's numbers look spot-on. I'd believe them the most.

B/S is a a good lab, but when they shouldn't have stood by their numbers - they should have known something was off with their numbers, and investigated thoroughly.
_________________________
2010 Kia Soul 2U - 2.0L I-4, auto, 89k miles.
MM Supreme 5W-30; QS 14612 filter.

Top
#1581320 - 08/28/09 02:00 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: Trav]
21Rouge Offline


Registered: 06/04/05
Posts: 1954
Loc: Vinegar Hill
Originally Posted By: Trav


Did you inform Petro what the sample was beforehand?
The numbers seem real close to what he told you they would be,
Do you get the feeling they just tweaked the numbers and actually tested nothing?



For sure I told them as I only made contact with them because the Blackstone numbers didnt seem right...two tests in a row! So the company knew I was sending in another sample of their 0W30 from the same bottle. Of course I have no idea what was actually done with my sample but given my correspondence with their rep. I take it at face value that it was tested.


Edited by 21Rouge (08/28/09 02:10 PM)

Top
#1581354 - 08/28/09 02:40 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: 21Rouge]
Jim 5 Offline


Registered: 05/25/05
Posts: 4009
Loc: Calgary Canada
The closeness of wearcheck to petrocan would make me suspect blackstone got the test/sample mixed up on first instance and fudged the numbers the second time. Just guessing though.
_________________________
Jim A
07.5 GMC Sierra 2500HD LMM Rotella 15w-40
09 Odyssey EX-L CT 5w-20
66 Bronco QS 10w-30
08 BMW K1200S Rt 15w-40
08 Pitster Pro X4 Rt 15w-40

Top
#1581357 - 08/28/09 02:42 PM Re: 3 diff. labs with samples taken frm the same b [Re: addyguy]
CATERHAM Offline


Registered: 11/18/05
Posts: 10133
Loc: Burlington, Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: addyguy
Wearcheck's numbers look spot-on. I'd believe them the most.

B/S is a a good lab, but when they shouldn't have stood by their numbers - they should have known something was off with their numbers, and investigated thoroughly.



+1

21Rouge, do you have the other VOA figures from Wearcheck including TBN?
_________________________
74 Lotus Europa, 5W-50
86 Porsche 928S, TGMO 0W-20 25% / M1 0W-40 75%
96 BMW 328i, Idemitsu/TGMO 0W-20 70% / M1 0W-40 30%
94 Caterham 7, FUCHS 0W-20

Top
Page 1 of 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >