Recent Topics
Vinegar ok to clean out swamp cooler lines?
by paulri
6 minutes 22 seconds ago
More on ASRC Fluid
by BrianF
27 minutes 16 seconds ago
Milesyn SXR 5w30
by Vlad_the_Russian
38 minutes 31 seconds ago
Downside for aftermarket OPE starters like this?
by mrsilv04
Today at 04:28 PM
2015 Chevy Traverse: severe sludge
by car51
Today at 03:55 PM
Striker fired pistol?
by Camprunner
Today at 03:13 PM
'Used' cars with delivery miles
by vinu_neuro
Today at 03:11 PM
139 MPH nut case
by CourierDriver
Today at 03:05 PM
Mountain, Snowflake?
by Camprunner
Today at 03:02 PM
M1 0w40, 9819 miles, 2010 BMW 328i
by Patman
Today at 02:46 PM
Opinion on used tires - BridgeStone Blizzak
by pacem
Today at 02:41 PM
GM recommendation: 15w50 for track driving
by dparm
Today at 01:15 PM
Fuel Pump Maintenance Tips
by Speak2Mountain
Today at 01:13 PM
Oil suggestions for 2017 Tacoma with 2TR-FE
by Matt_V
Today at 12:57 PM
Coolant update: 1996 Ford Bronco 302
by Sundodger
Today at 12:53 PM
HDEO 5w-40 vs Porsche A40 in 911 3.4 - Oil Foaming
by BufordTJustice
Today at 12:42 PM
Transmission pan gasket
by mickalo
Today at 12:41 PM
Which Tire Repair Kit?
by BlindBaby
Today at 12:23 PM
You know your car isn't driven often when...
by Astro14
Today at 12:16 PM
Strange brake feeling in my Accord
by Bottom_Feeder
Today at 12:12 PM
Newest Members
perplexed, TroyHayesDoyle, blueeyedme, anomalia, pack_run
61982 Registered Users
Who's Online
90 registered (A310, agpatel, 03s, 02s4audi, 555, 2009Edge, 8 invisible), 2441 Guests and 17 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
61982 Members
66 Forums
267122 Topics
4418009 Posts

Max Online: 3590 @ 01/24/17 08:07 PM
Donate to BITOG
Topic Options
#1142330 - 05/02/08 12:28 PM Pour Point Vs. Viscosity
byez Offline


Registered: 10/21/07
Posts: 434
Loc: Canada,North America,Western H...
I have been playing around quite a bit with the viscosity calculator at Esko.

I was comparing Mobil 1000 5w20 vs. Esso XD3 0w30.

Mobil 1000 5w20
cSt at 40C 46.7
cSt at 100C 8.4

Esso XD3 0w30
cSt at 40C 71
cSt at 100C 12.1

So here is where I am confused. The Mobil 1000 is a 5 weight while the XD3 is a 0 weight. So the 0 weight should have a lower viscosity at low temperatures? According to the calculator, the 5 weight has a lower viscosity at -10,-20,-30,-40C. Am is missing something here?

To further complicate things, the Mobil 1000 dyno has a pour point of -30C while the XD3 synthetic has a pour point of -48C. How can a lower viscosity product have a lower pout point than one that is much thicker at temperature extremes?

I am still unsure of what to make about CCS & MRV. Could someone also throw these into the big picture and explain how viscosity, pour point, ccs, & mrv contribute to making a good winter oil.


Top
#1142345 - 05/02/08 12:45 PM Re: Pour Point Vs. Viscosity [Re: byez]
MGregoir Offline


Registered: 08/30/07
Posts: 1784
Loc: Bonnyville, AB
The numbers from the Esko calculator are kinematic viscosity, instead of dynamic which is the Cold Crank Simulator and MRV pumpability tests.

CCS and MRV is used to determine the Winter grade of the oil. A 5W oil must be less than 6600 centipoise in the cold crank simulator at -30, and 60000 centipoise at -35 in the MRV cold pump test. These numbers tell the real story about cold performance. 0W is better than a 5W oil as it must perform better than a 5W oil performs at -35 at -40.

Dynamic viscosity, how well the oil pumps, rather than kinematic viscosity which is how well the oil flows.

Pour point is based on how much the oil thickens and kinematic viscosity (the centistoke numbers) to an extent, but it is caused by the chemical characteristics of the oil. Oils are based on parrafinic base stocks, and the more heavily de-waxed and saturated the hydrocarbons in the base oil, the better the pour point. There are also other chemicals that can be added to inhibit the formations of these wax crystals as the oil gets colder, which is what greatly effects pour point. PAO and esters generally have better pour points as they are synthesized, then group III oils because they are most heavily saturated (the higher the viscosity index of the base oils, generally the lower the pour point), then group II+ and group II oils. A better oil will generally have a better pour point.

BTW, Mobil Super 1000 is not worth the money relative to just about any other oil you can get off the shelf. They want Pennzoil price for Esso Extra product, IMHO. You are paying for it to come in a really pretty jug.

Top
#1142371 - 05/02/08 01:32 PM Re: Pour Point Vs. Viscosity [Re: byez]
marcel Offline


Registered: 04/14/07
Posts: 57
Loc: alberta,canada
If you don't mind a 40 wt. the Petro Canada Duron E 0W-40 has the lowest pour point of any oil, -66 C.

Top
#1142381 - 05/02/08 01:54 PM Re: Pour Point Vs. Viscosity [Re: marcel]
addyguy Offline


Registered: 09/08/05
Posts: 14067
Loc: Canada
MGregoir,

Gotta respectfully disagree on your point about Mobil 'Super 1000 (& 2000)' oils. Although I have no proof, I think these oils are slightly higher quality than regualr Esso Protec. Although Protec is a great oil, I think you will find these 'Super' oils are closer to add-pack and composition of Mobil Clean 5000 & 7500 oils, which have shown some really, reallt good UOA's on this board.

JMHO
_________________________
2010 Kia Soul 2U - 2.0L I-4, auto; 105k miles.
VWB 10W-30; OEM Kia filter.

Top
#1142399 - 05/02/08 02:26 PM Re: Pour Point Vs. Viscosity [Re: addyguy]
byez Offline


Registered: 10/21/07
Posts: 434
Loc: Canada,North America,Western H...
Actually I picked up a 5 litre jug of Mobil 1000 for around $12 on sale at Part Source. I couldn't resist. I might just use it for the summer and go back to synthetic in winter.

Thanks for clearing everything up MGregoir.

Top
#1142403 - 05/02/08 02:37 PM Re: Pour Point Vs. Viscosity [Re: addyguy]
MGregoir Offline


Registered: 08/30/07
Posts: 1784
Loc: Bonnyville, AB
I guess, but all things considered I can go buy 4.73 litres of Pennzoil for no more than $16.99 most places, and as little as $9.98 on sale. The Mobil Super 1000 is probably a good oil, maybe a little better than Extra, but for the price I don't think it's any bigger than the yellow bottle which is a known quantity.

I just can't see Canada being a big enough country to permit two products in the same space from the same manufacturer.

I would almost be willing to go buy a bottle of Extra 5W-30 and pay for a VOA on it if you were willing to do the same with a bottle of Super 1000 5W-30 at the same lab to compare notes.

I would say the Super 2000 is a better oil, but the value proposition on the Super 1000 is off.

Top
#1142468 - 05/02/08 03:55 PM Re: Pour Point Vs. Viscosity [Re: MGregoir]
mechtech2 Offline


Registered: 09/05/06
Posts: 19479
Loc: Chicago Area
40 deg C is not really cold, but middle warm. At O def F is where the oil's low temp rating is accurate.
In between temps will vary.

Top