Will buy again:
Firestone Destination A/T: very even wear, holds air well, good tread design, great rain traction, great price.
Might consider on a different vehicle:
Goodyear Eagle GTII: poor tire choice for a Ranger (was on the truck when I got it); wet traction was terrible, wear was uneven, tires would spin under any conditions. However, on a classic car that only sees sunny weather, I would possibly consider them if they were cheaper than comparable tires.
Will not buy again:
Sears Super Sport HT: very poor wet weather traction, truck can't even be driven over dry leaves, BUT tread wear is okay.
Continental ContiTrac: very poor traction, very fast and uneven wear. They were the OEM tire on my parents' 2002 Ranger 2WD. After 20,000 miles, they were toast. My parents are the speed limit driving type and do get their tires rotated.