Where are you going to use them most? Highway Tire - ATP - A/TX - Offroad Tire
The A/TX will be louder and offer better mud and loose pack snow traction.
The ATP, better wet and ice traction, though either still worse than a highway tire.
The customer ratings for the A/TX are nonsense, it's more like a 5/10 rather than the 8.2 ice and 9.1 wet (meaning average. not bad, for an ATX tire), but they may have been comparing to their old, worn out, hardened compound tires.
Last edited by Dave9; 12/15/19 07:50 PM.