Originally Posted by jrvn
Originally Posted by dave1251
Originally Posted by NYSteve
I'm not sure I still follow the 3 supplier issue. If Aisin contracts out to 3 blenders that exact spec that goes to Toyota, it really shouldn't matter (doesn't Supertech do this with Amalie, Warren etc?).
I went through a similar rabbit hole with BMW/Mini ATF6 spec and found the following chart from Aisin. To me, I trust the transmission manufacturer more so that the car manufacturer bc they actually built it, not requested a spec sheet.
https://www.be.aisin-europe.com/files/1915/1738/1940/PDS_Aisin_ATF6_Low.pdf
I add there is nothing nothing magical it's a transmission. It has a viscosity, coefficient, torque, and stability requirements. I don't know how this topic has turned into mythological theology.
READ THIS
Not a fan of Pat Goss but the Toyota vid is interesting.
I have a Lexus GX470 with the 4.7 V8 and 5 speed auto that I've run Amsoil Fuel Efficient ATF for 35k miles with no issue. Before that I have a Volvo 4 speed that I ran Redline D4 and Supertech Dex6 with the issues.
The Lexus had its first ATF flush at 75k miles and the Volvo around 115k miles both no issues.
I'm not putting down using only Toyota or Aisin fluid as you can see what I use. I have a Mini that has $45/quart sealer fluid. Will be using Aisin or Redline D4.
I think you are trying to find fluid that is cheaper that dealer, guaranteed to work, and is the exact spec but you can only pick two of those and that's why you keep coming back to Toyota fluid instead of Aisin.
At the end of the day you need to pick what will make you sleep at night and if you can live the consequences on you decision. If I mess up my atf flush or pick the wrong fluid I'm ok with paying for a new trans.
Are you if you go with Aisin over Toyota or vice versa or pick max life?