Originally Posted by slacktide_bitog
If winter performance is important, and you don't use separate tires for the winter, consider a 3-peak all-season tire. Walmart carries the Toyo Celsius for $119 each...
... For $100 each, you can get actual Goodyear tires that are not Walmart specials. The Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric AS. Out of stock now, but when they get them in, they are worth considering.
Although those Toyo Celsius are above the intended budget, and are a compromise tire achieving tread wear between that of a winter and all season, they are what I would get for an "all season" tire for Michigan winters, especially if in an area that gets lake-snow... depends, some vehicles *need* to be driven in snowy weather and some don't.
Goodyears's budget series tires, whether a model # special for walmart or not, are pretty underwhelming performers and I'd sooner go with a 2nd tier manufacturer's mid-grade tire. The Viva 3 has a 60K mi treadwear rating which on a tire this cheap (under $60 at other sellers before shipping?) makes it most likely it has a hard rubber compound that will do poorly in winter. This is typical for major brand budget tires, buying all-season for an area that gets significant snow and ice is one of the harder tire choices to make.