Better, Worse, or All The Same?

[CarbonSteel]

Based only on the attributes shown below, which oil would you choose and why? (Nothing scientific here, just something to discuss):

 

[SirTanon]

Picture is not showing for me.

 

[normal_guy1]

Is there any data on:

1) Oil spec ?
2) Price ?
3) Ease of obtainability ?
4) TBN ?

If i had to choose one based on the above data, I guess I'll go with "Oil A" simply because it's the first choice and my horoscope today says that I should be impulsive and make quick decisions when the moon is half-full and Mercury aligns with Venus in the night sky.

 

[dbias]

C

 

[CT8]

Why would i use the posted info to chose any of the oil?

 

[Rolla07]

Originally Posted by CT8
Why would i use the posted info to chose any of the oil?


This

Id go by recommended weight/s price and brand..

 

[dlundblad]

Why are the fuel %'s so different? Almost looks like an exponential trend considering the % to mileage ratio on oils D and E.

If all oils were treated the same service wise, it's a draw between B and C IMO.

 

[DGXR]

Not much information for making a decision.

 

[dave1251]

Originally Posted by DGXR
Not much information for making a decision.



This there is no information on oxidation, shear, TBN, engine and driving style. With what we have I'd say all the same.