Originally Posted by AZjeff
If my grandpa painted those stocks there's no doubt in my mind I'd keep the one I liked best alone and refinish the metal. Family heirloom right there.
I understand that line of reasoning. I've inherited some things that were similar. However, many of my grandfather's possessions were not his "prize possessions" and I was lucky enough to know which was which. I've carefully maintained the ones worthy of it, and did what I want with the rest.
I'll bet grandpa would be proud to have owned the lovingly restored versions. I think they look fantastic!!!!!! AND, I think you should display them proudly, each with a note attached about who owned it, where and when, and a little about the restoration.
Off topic a bit, but still relevant:
When I'm gone, I don't want my successors to think I prized much of the "stuff" I own.
It is a good idea to write about the things that have special value. And to leave disposal directions for the rest of the stuff. If I die today, there are clearly inherited things that may be discarded that are worthwhile family heirlooms. I need to get on the ball. Widowed women have a wonderful way of discarding grandpa's incredibly valuable model trains at goodwill. If you care, write down your wishes!!!!!!