I'd reuse it if the pan was fully scrubbed on your last pan drop and fill. As long as your QC is good in refiltering the fluid, you won't get any dirt in it. Use clean containers. Double filter it if you have too. $35 in trans fluid isn't exactly cheap. We have lots of members here running around to AAP/AZ/retail stores during clearance/roll back periods trying to save $10. I don't see any issue trying to save $35.
If a few minute particles of "whatever" did happen to go into the next pan fill, wouldn't your filter take it out any ways? What happens when people take their cars to the quick lubes or a dealer for a trans fluid pan drop and filter change? Do you think they scrub out every bit a sludge in that pan? I'm sure many don't. A quick dump, quick wipe and that pan goes right back on, with plenty of wear particles and dirt still in there. Get more use out of the new fluid you just added. You can always change it again later on.
If a few minute particles of "whatever" did happen to go into the next pan fill, wouldn't your filter take it out any ways? What happens when people take their cars to the quick lubes or a dealer for a trans fluid pan drop and filter change? Do you think they scrub out every bit a sludge in that pan? I'm sure many don't. A quick dump, quick wipe and that pan goes right back on, with plenty of wear particles and dirt still in there. Get more use out of the new fluid you just added. You can always change it again later on.
Last edited: