Recent Topics
Small Trolling Motors
by wings&wheels. 12/15/18 12:49 PM
Toyota Corolla, good and bad?
by jongies3. 12/15/18 12:35 PM
Mixing oils
by bfleeman. 12/15/18 10:51 AM
Ebay 10% off Tech 15% off everything else*.
by demarpaint. 12/15/18 10:39 AM
Milwaukee Fuel M12 Ratchet 1/4” vs 3/8”
by Snagglefoot. 12/15/18 10:16 AM
Hifly Hf 805
by chrisri. 12/15/18 10:00 AM
Preferred 5.3L L83 Oil Filter
by zfasts03. 12/15/18 09:58 AM
sonata plastic fork starter failed three times.
by JustinH. 12/15/18 09:17 AM
HVAC Problems
by WTJackalope. 12/15/18 09:15 AM
Rough Idle after short trip
by Datarock. 12/15/18 09:07 AM
Homelite 360
by mobilaltima. 12/15/18 09:04 AM
Lovin' the Etec!
by IndyFan. 12/15/18 06:10 AM
Air Impact Wrench
by BenZahel. 12/15/18 05:19 AM
Luber finer 750 bypass oil filter info
by BigRich954. 12/15/18 03:59 AM
Ford Pickup Front Wheel Bearings 2WD
by benjamming. 12/14/18 10:52 PM
GMC oil fill tube
by Redright9. 12/14/18 10:24 PM
Where do I buy Toto toilets? That has them!
by Vern_in_IL. 12/14/18 10:04 PM
Best filter cutter for the price?
by DONWATERS. 12/14/18 09:38 PM
5W-40 vs 10W-30 for a 2018 Audi A4
by jcr1293. 12/14/18 09:25 PM
Newest Members
Spkrdctr, torchredone12, JNG, Edmundo, NEKGuy
66688 Registered Users
Who's Online Now
82 registered members (53' Stude, 71Chevyguy, 4WD, 93cruiser, bbhero, 77GrandPrix, 8 invisible), 2,200 guests, and 45 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Forums67
Topics295,108
Posts4,927,944
Members66,688
Most Online2,553
Oct 27th, 2018
Donate to BITOG
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Hop To
Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? #4565984
11/06/17 02:56 PM
11/06/17 02:56 PM
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 21,122
Upstate NY
Donald Online content OP
Donald  Online Content OP
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 21,122
Upstate NY
My church had a major fire this morning.

http://wnyt.com/news/canaan-congregational-church-columbia-county-fire/4659820/?cat=10114
Columbia County church damaged by flames

The fire Dept said it was started in a 4 bulb ceiling fixture in vestibule. 3 LED bulbs and one broken socket. I installed the LED bulbs 2yrs ago. The broken socket was where someone twisted a bulb too tight and Odd the light would have been left on.

1830 church, no arc fault breakers.

Last edited by Donald; 11/06/17 03:09 PM.

2015 Subaru Forester 2.5 engine/CVT
2015 Ford F250 w/Powerstroke
2016 Subaru Crosstrek CVT (wife's)
Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566030
11/06/17 03:43 PM
11/06/17 03:43 PM
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 21,312
ON, Canada eh?
StevieC Offline
StevieC  Offline
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 21,312
ON, Canada eh?
A ground fault (GFCI) would be better because it depends on seeing an imbalance between Neutral and Hot.
Arc fault generally needs higher current to trip as I understand it and it may not see that with sparking.

In this instance because it's most likely converting the AC Voltage to DC using some sort of rectifying circuit so it may not see the arching whereas it would sense an imbalance. (I'm not an electrician though)

http://www.eaton.bz/ecm/groups/public/@pub/@electrical/documents/content/pct_346231.pdf

Last edited by StevieC; 11/06/17 03:47 PM.

'18 Dodge Grand Caravan GT - AMSOIL SS 5w20
'06 Santa Fe - 535,000km AMSOIL SS 0w30 / ATF
Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566058
11/06/17 04:14 PM
11/06/17 04:14 PM
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 420
Kentucky
Fsharp Offline
Fsharp  Offline
Joined: Dec 2015
Posts: 420
Kentucky
AFCI may have caught it as they work based on sensing irregular current flows. As such it could have sensed an arc between hot and neutral where a gfci can only sense if theres a short to ground. Of course they make combo units which would really be best.

Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566100
11/06/17 05:07 PM
11/06/17 05:07 PM
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 6,521
New England
gathermewool Offline
gathermewool  Offline
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 6,521
New England
GFCI breaker failed to stop a smoldering issue was had (high-resistance connection likely). No spark typically mean no GFCI trip. I think the same would be true for AFCI, if all of the actual current is traveling as it should, right? In the case of the church, if the improper install of the bulbs caused a partial connection that resulted in sparks or a ground, it might have tripped.

Our condo had a couple of smoldering issues due to old aluminum wiring connections. We had an electrician mitigate by installing pig-tails and Al-coded connections/receptacles/switches/etc. Well, a neighbor had a small fire not too long after, so the same electrician (who just so happened to be related to the management association who we've just fired smirk ) replaced our breakers with GFCI breakers for only the cost of the breakers.

I was the only person who brought up the fact that there was more to the problem that needed to be looked into and I also expressed my reservations about the effectiveness of GFCI breakers mitigating potentially high-resistance connections, which were the cause of the smoldering issues, including after the mitigation. I was really taken aback when it wasn't only the electrician who got defensive of the mitigation job when I asked if the fault could possibly be the electrician's doing and that we should consider having someone else check (or maybe just spot-check) his work.

Anyway, the GFCI breakers were approved to be installed by the same electrician. Not too long after, my wife called me at work and described an acrid odor only in our bedroom. Some investigation revealed that it was the receptacle the window A/C unit was plugged into. I told her to turn it off and open the bedroom breaker, so long as it was safe to do so - it was. Turns out, we had caught it just in time. The pig-tail and purple wire nut were charred to disintegration. The SAME electrician was able to come over and assess the situation within a couple of hours. He didn't outright say it, but implied that he was doing us a solid by leaving a picnic he was at to rush over. I very quickly replied back that our complex was experiencing MORE problems since he had "upgraded" our wiring several months ago than in the entire few years I had been there.


'14 Forester XT FA20DIT (Cobb Stage 1)
Edge 0W-40 + FU filter (64,774 miles)
'15 Legacy FB25 (OEM Stage, uh, neg. 7?)
Edge 0W-20 + FU filter (40,803 miles)
Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566195
11/06/17 06:57 PM
11/06/17 06:57 PM
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 33,571
ME
eljefino Offline
eljefino  Offline
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 33,571
ME
Depending on how (when) was wired there could have been hot wires in that fixture all the time and a "detour" wire going down to, and back from, the switch. So the over torqued bulb/ fixture could have cut into a hot wire even if the switch was off. Weird that it would spark at some random time but I wouldn't beat yourself up over it. Stuff happens.

Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566209
11/06/17 07:16 PM
11/06/17 07:16 PM
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 546
North Carolina
WANG Offline
WANG  Offline
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 546
North Carolina
AFCI are intended to prevent the situation that you describe here.


"Sportbikes have evolved from an axe into a scalpel.
Problem is, the average sportbike buyer is more lumberjack than surgeon." -Richard Pollock
Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566266
11/06/17 08:17 PM
11/06/17 08:17 PM
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 4,838
Central Texas
sleddriver Offline
sleddriver  Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 4,838
Central Texas
1830's?? Knob & tube wiring? Fuses or ckt brkrs?

Lots of variables to consider.


1998 Volvo V70 T5 228,880 mi. Original Owner.
M1 10W-30 HM
"It's never a mistake to buy tools, defined broadly. They're not a cost, they're an investment." - J.B. Peterson
Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566368
11/06/17 10:53 PM
11/06/17 10:53 PM
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,912
NC
GMFan Offline
GMFan  Offline
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,912
NC
Very ironic. Had a situation a number of years ago where I troubleshooted a fixture in the vestibule Id a church built in the 50s. Breaker would trip whenever light was turned on. Taking apart the fixture and examining the wiring showed that heat from the bulbs over the years wore down the insulation so the hot wire was suddenly contacting the grounded metal chassis of the fixture where the wiring entered. This caused a short circuit which tripped the circuit breaker.

Thing is...old circuit breakers that havent been switched or exercised in a long long time can basically fail and bind up to where they wont trip when theres a fault. The breaker mechanism can basically become stuck and let high current above what the wiring is rated for continue until you get a fire.

This is why it is recommended to periodically exercise all breakers by opening and closing them multiple times. Also, any breaker over say 30 years old should probably be replaced. In fact, Id say exercise breakers at least once a year and replace all breakers after 25 years.

Was the main panel fuses or breakers. What were type of breakers? Federal Pacific breakers are defective and have been recalled but lots are still in use.

Last edited by GMFan; 11/06/17 10:55 PM.

2011 Mazda6, 115k miles
Valvoline Maxlife 5W20, Napa ProSelect
"Muscles aching to work, minds aching to create - this is man."
Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: Donald] #4566528
11/07/17 07:42 AM
11/07/17 07:42 AM
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 1,083
ohio
caravanmike Offline
caravanmike  Offline
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 1,083
ohio
Yes more info is needed! What did the insurance company's engineer say caused it? What type of breakers/ fuses?
Fire investigators sometimes don't get it right! Especially volunteer ones with little resources! My guess is if the fire depts ladder truck is a 60's Peter Pirsch, then the resources they invest in fire investigation are zero?


Oils I use: Any 5w-30,5w-20 conventional

Re: Would arc fault breakers have prevented this? [Re: caravanmike] #4566578
11/07/17 08:43 AM
11/07/17 08:43 AM
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 21,936
Orlando, FL
Mr Nice Offline
Mr Nice  Offline
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 21,936
Orlando, FL
Originally Posted By: caravanmike
Yes more info is needed! What did the insurance company's engineer say caused it? What type of breakers/ fuses?
Fire investigators sometimes don't get it right! Especially volunteer ones with little resources! My guess is if the fire depts ladder truck is a 60's Peter Pirsch, then the resources they invest in fire investigation are zero?


I agree.

Its best not to do electrical work if you're not a licensed electrician and trying to help the church. A good deed comes back to bite you.



BOB IS THE OIL GUY® Powered by UBB.threads™