Recent Topics
Grade of Fuel for Snow Blower
by cb450sc. 12/11/18 04:36 PM
Heat Not Hot
by coopns. 12/11/18 04:30 PM
BMW or Volvo Transmission Rebuild
by kawan. 12/11/18 04:29 PM
Front brake pads
by Papa Bear. 12/11/18 03:38 PM
Another too much oil in the sump thread
by paulri. 12/11/18 03:15 PM
Honda and 2 different Frams
by mclasser. 12/11/18 02:19 PM
Fluctuating Tachometer
by jerseyguy123. 12/11/18 02:09 PM
Light weight non stick 11" fry pan suggestion
by PandaBear. 12/11/18 02:07 PM
Four 333d oil filters
by Burt. 12/11/18 01:51 PM
Exploding water heater
by Alfred_B. 12/11/18 01:16 PM
Donaldson P550335 - good for 10k or 1 year?
by leoblack9. 12/11/18 12:41 PM
Redline D4 or Honda atf
by Bullwinkle007. 12/11/18 12:28 PM
Gas dryer heat wont stay on more than 5 mins
by Brybo86. 12/11/18 11:58 AM
fuel additive for gas vehicles
by ugabulldog. 12/11/18 10:47 AM
Audio Repair Needed
by Redright9. 12/11/18 09:50 AM
GM dealer must install headlights?
by irv. 12/11/18 08:08 AM
Newest Members
EagleC, Dinka, MechanicGuy, syra1970, TheBirdman
66652 Registered Users
Who's Online Now
107 registered members (240_Ed, 2oldtommy, 28oz, 2004tdigls, ad244, 97f150, 15 invisible), 2,016 guests, and 36 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Forums67
Topics294,926
Posts4,924,433
Members66,652
Most Online2,553
Oct 27th, 2018
Donate to BITOG
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Hop To
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4
What really makes an oil a good oil? #4528461
09/28/17 12:21 PM
09/28/17 12:21 PM
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 44
South Florida
Invasivore Offline OP
Invasivore  Offline OP
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 44
South Florida
I see that many people are currently worried about additive levels being lowered (supposedly) in CK-4 oils, but what does that really mean for us in the real world? Are the additives the only thing we should really be worried about or is the base stock much more important for a reduction in wear. We all get caught up in comparing zinc, phosphate, boron, and moly numbers, but unless we are chemists, what the [censored] do we actually know?

What really makes an oil a good oil concerning diesels?

Last edited by Invasivore; 09/28/17 12:35 PM.
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: Invasivore] #4528469
09/28/17 12:31 PM
09/28/17 12:31 PM
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 2,561
South Carolina
alarmguy Offline
alarmguy  Offline
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 2,561
South Carolina
One of the best questions I ever saw posted in here.
Agree, everyone caught up in the limited scope of what an oil is tested for and why lately I have been of the mindset of whatever the API rating the manufacturer calls for is the best bet.

I personally, right or wrong, think film strength should be as important or more important. Im a little bit of a believer it RATS oil tests. (you can google rats test) trying not to hijack your questions because they are very valid.
Anyway, I cant answer your question and look forward to others, though I most likely will disagree if it goes much beyond whatever API grade the manufacturer call for ... :o) as I dont see tests backing up statements.

Last edited by alarmguy; 09/28/17 12:32 PM.

14 Road King (current)
08 VStar 1300 Tourer
07 Suzuki C50
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: alarmguy] #4528482
09/28/17 12:52 PM
09/28/17 12:52 PM
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 10,275
Upper Midwest
kschachn Offline
kschachn  Offline
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 10,275
Upper Midwest
Originally Posted By: alarmguy
I personally, right or wrong, think film strength should be as important or more important. Im a little bit of a believer it RATS oil tests. (you can google rats test) trying not to hijack your questions because they are very valid.

The problem is that even if you are correct about film strength being important, Rat's test is unable to distinguish between any of the oils tested. When his results are presented properly in accordance with the ASTM procedure, all oils test the same. So it is impossible to state that any one oil tests better or worse than any of the others.


1994 BMW 530i, 238K
1996 Honda Accord, 266K
1999 Toyota Sienna, 407K
2000 Toyota ECHO, 280K
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: kschachn] #4528536
09/28/17 02:14 PM
09/28/17 02:14 PM
Joined: Jan 2014
Posts: 593
Murray KY USA
GaleHawkins Offline
GaleHawkins  Offline
Joined: Jan 2014
Posts: 593
Murray KY USA
Originally Posted By: kschachn
Originally Posted By: alarmguy
I personally, right or wrong, think film strength should be as important or more important. Im a little bit of a believer it RATS oil tests. (you can google rats test) trying not to hijack your questions because they are very valid.

The problem is that even if you are correct about film strength being important, Rat's test is unable to distinguish between any of the oils tested. When his results are presented properly in accordance with the ASTM procedure, all oils test the same. So it is impossible to state that any one oil tests better or worse than any of the others.


I expect this has been the case for many years now but the marketing hype will continue. smile

Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: Invasivore] #4528592
09/28/17 03:25 PM
09/28/17 03:25 PM
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,509
Wet side WA
JohnnyJohnson Offline
JohnnyJohnson  Offline
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 3,509
Wet side WA
That it meets the API standard and its on sale at the best price!


2004 Corolla 126649
Out: VML 5w-30 TG4967 OCI 5007 Miles
In: EDGE EP 5W-30 Bosch 3311 122537 7-18-18
2006 Duramax 74478
Out: T6 5W-40 M1-303
In: T6 5W-40 XG9100 73705 4-22-18
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: alarmguy] #4528682
09/28/17 05:07 PM
09/28/17 05:07 PM
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 107
ST Augustine, FL
exShuttlemech Offline
exShuttlemech  Offline
Joined: May 2017
Posts: 107
ST Augustine, FL
me too, but I also believe in bypass filtration to get all of that fine particulate matter out of the oil (RAT doesn't), as it acts like lapping compound, IMHO.


2010 Rav4 4cyl 131K QSUD 0W20 Baldwin bypass filter
2003 4Runner 4.0L 219K 0W40 M1 Frantz bypass
2007 F150 4.2L 169K 5W30 QSUD
2016 NV2500
2017 RAV4
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: Invasivore] #4528751
09/28/17 06:29 PM
09/28/17 06:29 PM
Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 137
Colorado
Bronco1 Offline
Bronco1  Offline
Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 137
Colorado
Originally Posted By: Invasivore
I see that many people are currently worried about additive levels being lowered (supposedly) in CK-4 oils, but what does that really mean for us in the real world? Are the additives the only thing we should really be worried about or is the base stock much more important for a reduction in wear. We all get caught up in comparing zinc, phosphate, boron, and moly numbers, but unless we are chemists, what the [censored] do we actually know?

What really makes an oil a good oil concerning diesels?


I think your point is valid. I think MolaKule may be the only poster who meets the criteria. Even then, scientists don't all agree on the best approaches to additive packages. Compare the Ca/Mg approaches of Mobil Delvac vs Delo 400 SDE. You'll see that they both meet the standards but, in very different ways. Unless they can provide you (or you're willing to conduct) a well designed research project, recommendations are based on personal preference or anecdotal data. That's fine. People should pay for what they believe is best or, provides the best value for the money.

So, what makes an oil a good oil concerning diesels? Ask if it meets the current standards and if your vehicle manufacturer approves it and then do your homework and decide what you have confidence in. Call it and educated [censored] shoot ;-)


07 F150 Lariat 4x2
07 Honda Fit
96 Ford Bronco 4x4

"If you always do what you always did, you will always get what you always got" Albert Einstein
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: Invasivore] #4529011
09/29/17 03:38 AM
09/29/17 03:38 AM
Joined: Aug 2017
Posts: 49
South Oz, Australia
ozdrrider Offline
ozdrrider  Offline
Joined: Aug 2017
Posts: 49
South Oz, Australia
I went for the oil with runs on the board. Shell Rimula/Rotella in my case based on Special $ price at the the time helped (50% off) and old truckies and engine rebuilders I know swore by it.

Caltex/Chevron Delo. Mobil Delvac. all oils with >millions of miles on the board. Just choose the spec that suits your app. Oil test and monitor if you like, depending on your situation. Or just change at factory spec and sleep well at night. cool

Do that and the engine will be the last good thing left after all else fails around it!


15 Pajero 3.2 Penrite 10w40 full syn 50K km
06 Suzuki Swift Sport 1.6L 5w30 Nulon full syn
17 Suzuki DR650: Trialing LUBEALLOY LA 35 ES
83 350 Chev powered Ski Boat: Nulon 15w40
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: ozdrrider] #4529019
09/29/17 04:03 AM
09/29/17 04:03 AM
Joined: Jul 2015
Posts: 4,654
Down Under
SR5 Offline
SR5  Offline
Joined: Jul 2015
Posts: 4,654
Down Under
Originally Posted By: ozdrrider
I went for the oil with runs on the board. Shell Rimula/Rotella in my case based on Special $ price at the the time helped (50% off) and old truckies and engine rebuilders I know swore by it.

When I worked in the mines in outback Australia. We used Shell Rimula in everything.

One of the old diesel fitters gave up his old trade and became camp cook for the mines. His food was terrible, and we all reckoned he couldn't get his head around using vegetable oil for cooking and still used Shell Rimula. I don't know his real name, everybody called him Oil-Can-Harry.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Castrol GTX Ultraclean 15W40 A3/B3 + Wesfil-Cooper Z154
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: Invasivore] #4529924
09/29/17 10:17 PM
09/29/17 10:17 PM
Joined: Sep 2015
Posts: 6,075
Kalifornia Kollective
BrocLuno Offline
BrocLuno  Offline
Joined: Sep 2015
Posts: 6,075
Kalifornia Kollective
Engines are particular. I have real good luck with Delo 400 in small block Fords. Even with over 200,000 on the clock, they start quiet and run well. Pass SMOG testing w/o a hitch. Not so on Rotella T-6 ... And they rattle like crazy on Mobil1 ...

Chebies, not so much. Small block Mopars are easy on oil, so it does not make a lot of difference.

My Saab requires synthetic because of a design issue. The CAT is adjacent to the pan at the oil pump pick-up location. Let it idle in traffic much and it'll coke up the pick-up and starve the engine for oil. So it gets synthetic.

Point being "best oil" is application dependent. Listen the the engine, it'll tell you want it wants. Haunt the web sites for your particular car/truck and learn from other why something works better in one application.

Got a AA Fuel Digger (?), I'll bet you will be running Redline just for the ability to absorb ridiculous amounts of un-burned fuel and keep the parts lubed'ish.

Running an air cooled bike in the desert, I'll bet Motul 300V will be your go-to oil smile


Formerly in marine engineering. In an earlier life I owned my own petroleum tank truck, and hauled for the majors and independent's.
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: Invasivore] #4532437
10/02/17 08:12 PM
10/02/17 08:12 PM
Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 27
Indiana
redneck47441 Offline
redneck47441  Offline
Joined: Mar 2015
Posts: 27
Indiana
They all seem to me to have weakness and strengths. It's hard to say what the best is. I look at the base oil used first although that doesn't matter to those who know what they're talking about.

Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: BrocLuno] #4532460
10/02/17 08:42 PM
10/02/17 08:42 PM
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 7,481
Texas & Global
4WD Offline
4WD  Offline
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 7,481
Texas & Global
Again I ask what M1 - was it a 40 or 50? HDEO? You know HDEO competition is the closest group of oils there is - but T6 is 12% NOACK, yawn on HTHS, and that's poor for "synthetic' so when you question others for being "synthetic " you treat T6 (to use your words) like a nectar. The Delo & Delvac you use is better than T6 in any parameter that matters ... they are all doing coking tests - sos on that


2018 Chevy 1500 Z71 4WD
2017 Chevy Tahoe LT 4WD
2014 Fusion Hybrid Titanium
2013 Cruze LTZ - RS Turbo
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: Invasivore] #4532515
10/02/17 10:06 PM
10/02/17 10:06 PM
Joined: Sep 2015
Posts: 6,075
Kalifornia Kollective
BrocLuno Offline
BrocLuno  Offline
Joined: Sep 2015
Posts: 6,075
Kalifornia Kollective
The last M1 I tried was 10W-30 from Costco. Went in the Beemer and then the Saab when the Beemer was sold and the Saab replaced it. Came out of the Saab in a week at less than 500 miles because of start-up noise. Went into the Bronco as it was nearly new oil. Bronco hated it. Actually heard light rod knocks on cold start. That was the last try for me. Came out of the Bronco and was recycled ...

T6 is not magic oil. But it's OK for a lot of applications. I'd take JD 50+ over T6 any day if I could get it easily and as cheaply ... The reason I mention T6 a fair amount it it seems it will fit the application and lots of others here are OK with it. Sort of like the anti-M1 oil. It's on the Allison list, so I know it's good enough. It's not like I'm advocating Golden Spectro or something ...

Have new (to me) truck with about 88K on a 351W. When it's time for a change. I'll give M1 another try. I think I still have two jugs. Motor is tight enough it should not matter. But I'll predict that by 150K, it will start to be noisy on cold start on M1if I use it that long ...

The Delo applications for me have been moving into the 15W-30 SD that I now have plenty of. But I'll use up my stash of other stuff like BMW brand 5W-30 LL (I got it free) and some Castrol RS I got at the same time. Both are "true" EU synthetics. I have some QSAD 10W-30 to use up too. Since the 1970 C-20 is sold, I dunno what that's going into ...

Fall is here and it's time to change many vehicles. I'll have to figure out my plan of attack. I'm sure my remaining M1 will go into something before Christmas ... The goal is to get down to 2 oils for most stuff. Something lighter and a xxW-40 for where it's needed ... I'll store 6~10 gallons of each at a whack. I need the current qt(s) shelf space for other stuff like 2-stroke oil ...

Last edited by BrocLuno; 10/02/17 10:14 PM.

Formerly in marine engineering. In an earlier life I owned my own petroleum tank truck, and hauled for the majors and independent's.
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: kschachn] #4533494
10/04/17 05:25 AM
10/04/17 05:25 AM
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 2,561
South Carolina
alarmguy Offline
alarmguy  Offline
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 2,561
South Carolina
Originally Posted By: kschachn
Originally Posted By: alarmguy
I personally, right or wrong, think film strength should be as important or more important. Im a little bit of a believer it RATS oil tests. (you can google rats test) trying not to hijack your questions because they are very valid.

The problem is that even if you are correct about film strength being important, Rat's test is unable to distinguish between any of the oils tested. When his results are presented properly in accordance with the ASTM procedure, all oils test the same. So it is impossible to state that any one oil tests better or worse than any of the others.


Exactly, I agree. All oil tests the same and honestly, except for the massive marketing departments of some of these giant oil companies.

"all oils test the same". Those are excellent words and I will be using them in these forums in the future *LOL*

Ok, then as you know, we go outside the box in these forums and we or some of us chime in on why this oil or that oil is better because of its add pack, this one is more quiet, this one more noisy, this one more moly, this one less, etc etc.
What I am saying is, to me, within that context, RATS tests are more valid then speculation about an oil being better because of an additive package.
I would prefer an actual physical test on something, whether it is relevant or not, over someones words on why something is better without a physical test. Simply because words are just that, words.

Dont mis understand me, Im not pushing an agenda, I have always said, pick any oil within the recommended type and grade at any price and any brand and you are good to go. Its up to the engine manufacturer to properly build and design an engine.

We do, as I do have preferences. I agree again with some other post in here, choose an oil in the grade recommended and you will find some that the engine is more quiet, etc, etc. That makes more sense, then choosing an oil with a certain additive package based only on marketing.
Personally I like quiet and believe it or not, 90% or more of the time I use plain old conventional oils. I never had an engine failure in my life, never had an engine burn oil in my life. I simply change at the recommended OCI or before, normally before.

Again to the OP. This was one of the most refreshing threads in here, one that actually makes us think and discuss.

Last edited by alarmguy; 10/04/17 05:32 AM.

14 Road King (current)
08 VStar 1300 Tourer
07 Suzuki C50
Re: What really makes an oil a good oil? [Re: alarmguy] #4533510
10/04/17 05:48 AM
10/04/17 05:48 AM
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 41,520
'Stralia
Shannow Offline
Shannow  Offline
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 41,520
'Stralia
Rat can't even describe what the "film" is...

In actual lubrication, there's such a thing as "minimum oil film thickness", which is hydrodynamic/EHD, is calculable in the rigid definition, or in the elastic regime.

RAT discounts all regular tribology for engine oils, and then calculates is "film strength" based on an assumed applied pressure over the estimated wear scar area...i.e. the oil has failed at "keeping them separated", which makes it at best an additive test, which is why these tests are typically used for gears and roller bearings.

Then he goes on about the meaningless of NOACK, as his smoke test is better.

HTHS viscosity doesn't show in his additive test, so it's immediately discounted as real too.

There are truckloads of "physical tests" in the API suite...and they are all very very expensive.

So if RAT were ale to demonstrate that HIS physical test was at least as good as the (expensive) Sequence IVA warmup wear test, then he'd be rich, and the test would be his test rig, not an (expensive) old Nissan engine.

He claims it's not the one armed bandit, then goes all one armed bandit fair ground on his conclusions.

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4

BOB IS THE OIL GUY® Powered by UBB.threads™