Recent Topics
Michelin jack won't lift a load
by 10WSmuckers. 09/23/18 01:32 AM
Synthetic for a 30 year old engine?
by geissjr. 09/23/18 01:02 AM
Phone Books
by csandste. 09/23/18 12:11 AM
Inside the Fuel Tank / EVAP system
by StevieC. 09/22/18 10:31 PM
Toyota Pink + RMI-25 10 years
by burla. 09/22/18 10:27 PM
Cartridge filter?
by Camprunner. 09/22/18 10:23 PM
Should have changed it?
by parshisa. 09/22/18 10:14 PM
Meijer QSUD Full Syn 10w30 $8.11 5qt jug
by Spartanfool. 09/22/18 08:40 PM
Whats in your beef burger
by CourierDriver. 09/22/18 08:28 PM
Headlight brightness fluctuates on 1987 Golf
by vavavroom. 09/22/18 07:56 PM
"New" Beater
by SilverGt. 09/22/18 07:22 PM
Eschewing computer controls
by buck91. 09/22/18 06:41 PM
Leak/drip left front 13 Ram 4x4?
by irv. 09/22/18 06:22 PM
5w20 oil choices
by 53' Stude. 09/22/18 06:05 PM
site security
by RF Overlord. 09/22/18 06:02 PM
Richmond Raceway
by Warstud. 09/22/18 06:01 PM
Redline D6 ATF substituting for Toyota WS
by Patrick0525. 09/22/18 05:29 PM
XG3614 Cut Open 13,400kms (8,375mi)
by mcwilly. 09/22/18 05:25 PM
Torn Purolators: they DO TEAR!
by 53' Stude. 09/22/18 05:07 PM
Newest Members
HondaTech250, SandCruzer, sbgti96, cosmoblau, Sarrge
66044 Registered Users
Who's Online Now
28 registered members (aleneros, csandste, Bailes1992, BlakeB, 5 invisible), 777 guests, and 39 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Forums67
Topics290,867
Posts4,851,566
Members66,044
Most Online3,590
Jan 24th, 2017
Donate to BITOG
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Hop To
Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 #4528197
09/28/17 08:05 AM
09/28/17 08:05 AM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Saw the following in this Amsoil PDF:

Quote:
In recent years, API and ILSAC have reduced the ash content in engine oil to below 0.80% (max) by weight to meet API SM, ILSAC GF-4 specifications. Because all SAE xW-20 engine oils are required to have low ash, there is less tendency for carbon formation when they are burned in the combustion chamber.


I'd love for this to be true, but I haven't found evidence for it yet. For example, Infineum's summary of API and ILSAC specs makes no mention of sulfated ash for SM/GF-4, SN/GF-5, etc.

Was this statement an error on Amsoil's part, or am I missing something?


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528238
09/28/17 08:50 AM
09/28/17 08:50 AM
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
MolaKule Offline
MolaKule  Offline
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
Send a PM to Pablo.


Reading is fundamental; understanding is not a given ability.
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528268
09/28/17 09:19 AM
09/28/17 09:19 AM
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 11,851
Idaho
CT8 Online content
CT8  Online Content
Joined: Oct 2014
Posts: 11,851
Idaho
I would wonder if Amsoil is hyping the new additive package reformulations they are purchasing.


2015 Ford F150 2.7
2018 Ford F350 6.2
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528290
09/28/17 09:58 AM
09/28/17 09:58 AM
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,225
New England
Virtus_Probi Offline
Virtus_Probi  Offline
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,225
New England
I see that SN-RC directly specifies phosphorus and sulfur content...0.06-0.08% P and 0.5% max S for 0/5WXX.
Looks like there are similar limits for SM.


2014 Forester XT, 86000 miles
Last Change;
M1 5W30 d1G2
Tokyo Roki 15208AA170 filter
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528363
09/28/17 11:19 AM
09/28/17 11:19 AM
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,367
Alaska
m37charlie Offline
m37charlie  Offline
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,367
Alaska
Unless the periodic table has changed, metal sulfates aren't "carbon". It appears Amsoil does not know what it is talking about.

Charlie


05 Unimog U500/Unicat camper/Delvac 1 SHC ACEA E4/E5
09 BMW X5 35d/Delvac1 LE 5W30
88 Toyota OJ50LV OM314 motor D1 SHC
52 Dodge M37/Hercules diesel

Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: Virtus_Probi] #4528381
09/28/17 11:50 AM
09/28/17 11:50 AM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Originally Posted By: Virtus_Probi
I see that SN-RC directly specifies phosphorus and sulfur content...0.06-0.08% P and 0.5% max S for 0/5WXX.
Looks like there are similar limits for SM.

Sulfated ash is different from P and S, though they're all part of SAPS.

Thinking about it now, maybe whoever wrote that Amsoil doc made that same mistake. That'd be an awfully junior-grade mistake for an oil blender, but weirder stuff has happened....


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528405
09/28/17 12:19 PM
09/28/17 12:19 PM
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,225
New England
Virtus_Probi Offline
Virtus_Probi  Offline
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,225
New England
Originally Posted By: d00df00d
Originally Posted By: Virtus_Probi
I see that SN-RC directly specifies phosphorus and sulfur content...0.06-0.08% P and 0.5% max S for 0/5WXX.
Looks like there are similar limits for SM.

Sulfated ash is different from P and S, though they're all part of SAPS.

Thinking about it now, maybe whoever wrote that Amsoil doc made that same mistake. That'd be an awfully junior-grade mistake for an oil blender, but weirder stuff has happened....


This has always confused me, seems like ash is often used as a synonym for SAPS and even XOM refers to the Sulfated Ash level of their oils when I'm pretty sure that they mean SAPS. Anyway, I thought info I gave might be germane to the discussion...like you, I don't see any specific reference to SAPS in SN or its cousins.


2014 Forester XT, 86000 miles
Last Change;
M1 5W30 d1G2
Tokyo Roki 15208AA170 filter
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528441
09/28/17 12:58 PM
09/28/17 12:58 PM
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
MolaKule Offline
MolaKule  Offline
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
For ASTM D6335, the total deposit formation was cut by 15 mg. from the SL to SM transition and the ASTM D7097 deposit formation value was cut almost in half.

From the 2009 Amsoil TSB linked above:

Quote:
CARBON DEPOSITS:
As noted in the Mazda bulletin, carbon formation in the RENESIS
engine can lead to engine misfire and knocking. Carbon
deposit formation may not be due to the type of base oil, but
can also be related to the ash content of the oil additive package.
Higher ash content oils can form more carbon deposits
than lower ash content oils.

In recent years, API and ILSAC have reduced the ash content
in engine oil to below 0.80% (max) by weight to meet API
SM, ILSAC GF-4 specifications. Because all SAE xW-20
engine oils are required to have low ash, there is less tendency
for carbon formation when they are burned in the combustion
chamber.


The TSB never said anything about Sulfated Ash.

Any type of ash deposit can mix with the oil and further contribute to oil degradation.

Last edited by MolaKule; 09/28/17 01:01 PM.

Reading is fundamental; understanding is not a given ability.
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528455
09/28/17 01:14 PM
09/28/17 01:14 PM
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
MolaKule Offline
MolaKule  Offline
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
In Analytical Chemistry there are two forms of ash residue:

The residues after a sample is completely burnt consists mostly of metal oxides.

The ash remaining after incomplete combustion could contain any number of chemical species, including inorganic and organic.

Last edited by MolaKule; 09/28/17 01:17 PM.

Reading is fundamental; understanding is not a given ability.
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528464
09/28/17 01:23 PM
09/28/17 01:23 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Thanks for the clarification and elaboration, MolaKule!

Are you suggesting that the deposit formation specs for SM/GF-4 provide a way to get to that 0.8% figure? When I found that Infineum doc, I just searched for the word "ash" and only found it in the diesel specs.


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528474
09/28/17 01:38 PM
09/28/17 01:38 PM
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
MolaKule Offline
MolaKule  Offline
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA


Ash, in general chemistry terms, is the residue of complete or incomplete combustion and contains mostly solids.

Quote:
The ash remaining after incomplete combustion could contain any number of chemical species, including inorganic and organic.


This can include carbonaceous residues.


Reading is fundamental; understanding is not a given ability.
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528480
09/28/17 01:49 PM
09/28/17 01:49 PM
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
MolaKule Offline
MolaKule  Offline
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
Here was the kicker for me:

Quote:
Mazda Engineering did state that “not all synthetic oil is at a disadvantage in terms of carbon buildup, but use of untested, non-genuine oil should be avoided.”


I.e., use only XXX from the dealer; Hmmm, where have we heard that before?


Reading is fundamental; understanding is not a given ability.
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: d00df00d] #4528485
09/28/17 01:56 PM
09/28/17 01:56 PM
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
MolaKule Offline
MolaKule  Offline
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 19,235
Iowegia - USA
Originally Posted By: d00df00d
Thanks for the clarification and elaboration, MolaKule!

Are you suggesting that the deposit formation specs for SM/GF-4 provide a way to get to that 0.8% figure? When I found that Infineum doc, I just searched for the word "ash" and only found it in the diesel specs.


Amsoil, IMO, should have stated what the basis of their 0.8% figure was referenced to. I think (not sure) they meant relative to the transition from SJ/SL to SM GF-4, considering the time frame in which it was written. ???

Either way, I agree that it was poorly written and certainly not written by an analytical or physical chemist. shocked2

Last edited by MolaKule; 09/28/17 02:00 PM.

Reading is fundamental; understanding is not a given ability.
Re: Amsoil claim: ash limits for API SM / ILSAC GF-4 [Re: Virtus_Probi] #4528610
09/28/17 05:04 PM
09/28/17 05:04 PM
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 25,384
Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada
Garak Online content
Garak  Online Content
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 25,384
Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada
Originally Posted By: Virtus_Probi
This has always confused me, seems like ash is often used as a synonym for SAPS and even XOM refers to the Sulfated Ash level of their oils when I'm pretty sure that they mean SAPS. Anyway, I thought info I gave might be germane to the discussion...like you, I don't see any specific reference to SAPS in SN or its cousins.

SA has a specific definition and is a component of certain HDEO specifications. For instance, you'll find E7, E9 lubricants having SA of 1 or less, because the specification combination requires that.

SAPS levels seem to be treated a little differently as to what's called/marketed as high/mid/low when it comes to ACEA specs for passenger vehicles versus the commercial side. I don't think it's quantifiable in the same way as SA with simply one number.


Plain, simple Garak.

2008 Infiniti G37 - Shell ROTELLA T6 Multi-Vehicle 5w-30, NAPA Gold 7356
1984 F-150 4.9L - Quaker State GB 10w-30, Wix 51515

BOB IS THE OIL GUY® Powered by UBB.threads™