Personal anecdote with topic sizing. 01 Civic OEM size 185/65-15. In 2004 Honda went to 195/60-15 on the same vehicle, no major redesign, same generation. First set of tires I purchased for it at Discount Tire was the 195/60-15, in 04 iirc. I preferred the slightly wider tire over the narrower oem. Discount Tire has never questioned it, and I've used the 60 series tire on it since with each DT purchase. Including current, four sets total.
Normally I stick with the oem size, but on that vehicle the 60 series has worked well. That said, your results could be different.