Recent Topics
Adding fuel filter- Generator built with no filter
by rubberchicken. 09/23/18 09:57 PM
Clutch Engaging too low
by Spetz. 09/23/18 09:41 PM
SMA - Krown previously, Fluid Film Application
by StevieC. 09/23/18 09:21 PM
First Paint Correction
by RayCJ. 09/23/18 08:33 PM
2011 Dodge Caliber
by dogememe. 09/23/18 07:48 PM
Mixing transmission fluids - partial change
by spk2000. 09/23/18 07:31 PM
Counterfeit MANN filter???
by IllinoisSparky. 09/23/18 06:54 PM
The smell of an oil: VME adds?
by fdcg27. 09/23/18 06:48 PM
Classic road brake pads
by buck91. 09/23/18 06:18 PM
Air up your vehicle's tires
by Papa Bear. 09/23/18 06:07 PM
A cool litttle Fall foliage site
by Papa Bear. 09/23/18 06:02 PM
Suggestion: "Likes"
by SnowDrifter. 09/23/18 05:36 PM
Condensation in headlights?
by irv. 09/23/18 05:06 PM
Nissan VQ V-6 Engines
by Al. 09/23/18 04:57 PM
List of dexos licensed oils?
by k1xv. 09/23/18 04:24 PM
High flow oil pump? Thinner oil?
by SnowDrifter. 09/23/18 04:06 PM
Is Tiger back?
by gman2304. 09/23/18 03:51 PM
Newest Members
Lilshady, SevenDu, sigpro, RayCJ, yellow97tt6spd
66055 Registered Users
Who's Online Now
61 registered members (asiancivicmaniac, ammolab, aquariuscsm, Auae85, 4WD, 4 invisible), 1,282 guests, and 34 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Statistics
Forums67
Topics290,917
Posts4,852,486
Members66,055
Most Online3,590
Jan 24th, 2017
Donate to BITOG
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Hop To
Page 1 of 2 1 2
Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs #4444539
06/29/17 05:47 AM
06/29/17 05:47 AM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Currently working on oil choice for two applications:

1. Completely stock. Calls for ISLAC GF-4 (API SM with starburst) 5w-20. Potential for high heat and high fuel dilution. Prone to carbon deposit formation. Burns oil @ 1 qt/1k miles, but MUST preserve the catalytic converter. 5k max OCIs.

2. Mostly stock. Called for API SG 7.5w-30 originally (rare spec); later updated to SJ, 5w-30/10w-30/10w-40. Twin-turbocharged, ~120 hp/L @ 0.7 bar boost (maybe more in the future). No catalytic converter. 3k-5k OCIs.


Had a thought or two about going a different route from the usual "any OTS synthetic" or "Red Line/Amsoil/whatever" knee-jerk reaction. Hoping for some informed feedback here.

Mechanically, neither application seems particularly demanding. Also, OCIs will be short no matter what oil is used. That seems to leave plenty of room to focus on other things. For the first app, I'd like something that resists and controls high temp deposits, keeps the engine squeaky-clean inside, and will be extra nice to the catalytic converter. The second app affords much more freedom (less oil burning, no cat to poison), but I figure there's no sense picking a dirty oil if it's not necessary; cleaner can only help.

Based on that, I figure that if I can find low ash oils that still meet demanding specs, they'd probably be good candidates. No sense in a super-robust additive package when a lower-ash one can get the job done with fewer deposits.

Here are some examples from Lubrizol's Relative Performance Tool (link): low ash specs with very high scores for "piston deposits" and "oxidative thickening", while maintaining high scores for wear control.

MB 229.52 and MB 229.71 in the "Passenger Car" section:


MB 228.61 in the "Heavy Duty Vehicle" section:


AFAIK, 229.52 is okay for gas engines; 229.71 may or may not be, but at least one of the oils that meets it also carries gas engine specs. Can't tell about 228.61, but I suspect application #2 would be fine with it either way.

Given all that, am I right to imagine that these would be decent candidates for the applications described above? Are there shortcomings to these specs that might be relevant to the applications as I described them?


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4444646
06/29/17 08:38 AM
06/29/17 08:38 AM
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
2004tdigls Offline
2004tdigls  Offline
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
try a VW 507 diesel engine oil, the ash level is even lower than a API CJ oil but the additive pack is designed to allow 10K oil change intervals

http://www.oilspecifications.org/articles/vw_motor_oil_specifications_explained.php

http://germanoem.ca/parts/chemicals/engi...w30-oil-1l.html


Last edited by 2004tdigls; 06/29/17 08:48 AM.
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: 2004tdigls] #4444658
06/29/17 08:47 AM
06/29/17 08:47 AM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Interesting! Thanks for the tip. 507 looks like a heck of a spec.

Lubrizol has the SA limit for VW 507 listed as 1.5%, which is higher than API CJ-4 at 1%. Is that an error on their part?


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4444678
06/29/17 09:00 AM
06/29/17 09:00 AM
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
2004tdigls Offline
2004tdigls  Offline
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
VW limits SA in 507 oils to 0.8% to protect the diesel particle filter, so it appears that the Lubrizol site it not correct

this tdi club thread explains the difference between an API CJ oil and a VW 507 oil (see too slick' comments)

http://forums.tdiclub.com/showthread.php?t=278663

Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4444682
06/29/17 09:07 AM
06/29/17 09:07 AM
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 36,304
Great Lakes
Quattro Pete Offline
Quattro Pete  Offline
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 36,304
Great Lakes
Originally Posted By: d00df00d

Lubrizol has the SA limit for VW 507 listed as 1.5%, which is higher than API CJ-4 at 1%. Is that an error on their part?

I was wondering about that, but even Afton Chemical Spec Handbook lists SA limit of 1.5% for VW 507.00 spec. However, as was mentioned earlier, most VW 507.00 oils also meet ACEA C3 spec, and that one does limit SA to 0.8%.


'02 530i (Edge 0W-40)
'15 Q5 3.0T (Edge 5W-40)
'18 Charger SRT (FF)
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: 2004tdigls] #4444683
06/29/17 09:07 AM
06/29/17 09:07 AM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Got it. Thanks again. Also noticed Mobil 1 ESP Formula 5w-30 (their 507-approved product) is at 0.6%, so that's good, too. :]

Any thoughts on this strategy for the applications I described?


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4444710
06/29/17 09:23 AM
06/29/17 09:23 AM
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
2004tdigls Offline
2004tdigls  Offline
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
well for application #1 you could try a 7500 mile oci (with analysis), the 507 oils are really tough and are designed to take soot from huge egr rates, cooking from dpf regeneration and resist shearing from the drivetrain. 507 oils are also approved for the PD engines which consume their camshafts at an alarming rate.

Guys over at the TDI club find tbn retention is excellent with tbn levels in the 2-3 range (or higher) even after 10K miles in a diesel engine. Lots of good reading here

http://forums.tdiclub.com/showthread.php?t=154548

I really dont have any suggestion for application #2, I am not familiar with that engine.

Last edited by 2004tdigls; 06/29/17 09:24 AM.
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4444736
06/29/17 09:37 AM
06/29/17 09:37 AM
Joined: Dec 2016
Posts: 6,258
Waco, TX
Linctex Offline
Linctex  Offline
Joined: Dec 2016
Posts: 6,258
Waco, TX
Originally Posted By: d00df00d

2. Mostly stock. Called for API SG 7.5w-30 originally (rare spec); Twin-turbocharged, ~120 hp/L @ 0.7 bar boost


What vehicle is this?


"The evidence demands a verdict".
(Re:VOA)"it's nearly impossible to actually know the particular additives that are in there at what concentrations."
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: Linctex] #4444938
06/29/17 12:50 PM
06/29/17 12:50 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Knew someone would ask. :]

I'd prefer not to name the vehicles, mainly because I suspect it would derail the thread. For now, I'm mainly focused on assessing the reasoning I laid out.


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4445160
06/29/17 04:37 PM
06/29/17 04:37 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Man, I wish the Lubrizol tool were useful for comparing between specs. It'd be nice to compare VW 507 against those MB specs.


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4445203
06/29/17 05:26 PM
06/29/17 05:26 PM
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
2004tdigls Offline
2004tdigls  Offline
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 497
maple ridge, bc
its there, look under passenger oils, vw 504/507

https://online.lubrizol.com/relperftool/pc.html

Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4445218
06/29/17 05:48 PM
06/29/17 05:48 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Look at the note in italics to the right:
Quote:
NOTE: These performance charts are primarily designed to demonstrate relative performances within the same industry specification, for example, ACEA E6 versus ACEA E7, or API CH-4 versus API CJ-4. This tool has not been expressly designed to show relative performances between different specifications.

I've only skimmed on this, but it seems to me that VW 507 and the MB 22x.xx specs measure wear using different tests. I'm sure Lubrizol has opinions about how they compare, but anything beyond that seems tough to do in a valid way.


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4446451
07/01/17 06:12 AM
07/01/17 06:12 AM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Here's a question: Any worry about a lack of detergency or other cleaning abilities with oils like these?


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4526077
09/25/17 06:32 PM
09/25/17 06:32 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
d00df00d Offline OP
d00df00d  Offline OP
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 11,364
PA
Bump for feedback on this...
Originally Posted By: d00df00d
Here's a question: Any worry about a lack of detergency or other cleaning abilities with oils like these?


...and a minor update or two.

Still deciding for App #1. Cost-no-object, a 229.71 oil would have been my choice, but it seems there are only two in existence and neither is available Stateside. I've only looked at a couple of other low-ash options (Mobil 1 ESP X1 0w-30 and ESP Formula 5w-30); those are tempting but expensive. Anyone know of any other potential options, preferably ones that are available in bigger jugs?

App #2 ended up going with Castrol Edge 0w-40. It's available in jugs for less than half the per-quart cost of the low ash options, and it's closer to the viscosities and additization most people use in that application, so the owner didn't feel like being adventurous.


2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Mobil Super 5w-20
Re: Tough low-ash OE specs, API SJ/SM apps, short OCIs [Re: d00df00d] #4526762
09/26/17 01:47 PM
09/26/17 01:47 PM
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,296
NJ
bluesubie Offline
bluesubie  Offline
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,296
NJ
A lot of WRX and STI owners are running Mobil 1 ESP or Motul X-clean at 3-5k intervals in hopes of mitigating carbon deposits/LSPI. Looks like Motul has revamped its X-clean offerings (there are now three) so surely one of those or Motul Specific would fit the bill. Some of them list the SA levels on the data sheet and some do not.

There are now a total of nine Motul 5W-30's!


'04 Subaru Forester 2.5XT
Castrol Edge High Mileage
Page 1 of 2 1 2

BOB IS THE OIL GUY® Powered by UBB.threads™