There are plenty of us that ride/have ridden in sub-freezing temps. I personally have been going up and over the Bear Tooth Mountain pass into YNP in 3" of snow on my Valkyrie Interstate. What a posterior-puckering experience that was. I think that the temps were around +25 degF. It was a choice we made to experience the "adventure" of it all. Not smart, but certainly exciting. In general, two wheeled travel at sub-freezing temps is an ill-advised mode of transporation.
Back on topic; cold pumpability of your typical HDEO oil is NOT an issue when you're barely sub-freezing (say +25 deg and up). Cold pumpability IS an issue when you're talking -10 degF, but I doubt many people ride in that kind of weather.
That's why I contend that synthetics for motorcycles are a non-issue regarding cold weather.
If you're riding at -10degF or lower, then synthetics would be recommended. And I'd be the first to admit you're a tougher man than I am riding in that cold. But then, the insanity comment might just have more relavance at that point!