Jim, the compressor oil does not have to deal with byproducts of combustion, which is the main thing the TBN alkaline reserve capacity is there for in engine oil. Different additives are used in compressors than internal combustion engines due to the vast temp differences and lack of combustion process in a compressor. In the case of the compressor, some of the engine oil additives can actually be a detriment to the valves in the head of the compressor. At a friend's shop, they were running castrol 10W-40 engine oil in their large transmission shop compressors and having to replace or repair way too often and those big compressors are EXPENSIVE. The compressors would have to work harder and hotter as they lost efficiency, eventually stopped compressing altogether. My friend, the son-in-law, had started using Amsoil products and, on his own, took an interest in the shop compressors outside in the shed, changing out the engine oil for Amsoil's PC series compressor oil, using SAE 20, 40 and mostly a mixture of the two. To the owner's delight, their repairs and replacements on these 2 air compressors was reduced to zero. Granted, the compressors really had no one looking after them before this time, so any kind of attention or fluid replacement had to have helped the situation. After his success, I began using the same compressor oils and found that the PC series works well, but the part I like is that it supposedly has 8X the service life, so I should not have to change it as often as I would regular compressor oil, which has little, if any additives.
FWIW, I saw the same blurb on the Schaeffer website about their PAO compressor oils: 8X the life, or possibly better with oil analysis, so Amsoil's claim may be realistic. I've heard that Amsoil is very competitive pricewise in the industrial lubes market when comparing apples to apples. I can't remember how much I paid for a case of PC series compressor oil, but it seems like it was around $7 a quart or thereabouts.
FWIW, I saw the same blurb on the Schaeffer website about their PAO compressor oils: 8X the life, or possibly better with oil analysis, so Amsoil's claim may be realistic. I've heard that Amsoil is very competitive pricewise in the industrial lubes market when comparing apples to apples. I can't remember how much I paid for a case of PC series compressor oil, but it seems like it was around $7 a quart or thereabouts.