I agree with you completely.To each his own on maintenance records I suppose.
They help me flush out 2 otherwise identical cars for sale..
After owning and maintaining cars for a lifetime I know the kinds of repairs I should be looking at in a vehicle between 50-200K, and want to see some evidence whats been done.
Certain pieces are critical to provide evidence of being done - A timing belt car with no record of it being changed by 100K - immediately needs a belt regardless of the owners claim.
I prefer a manual log thats laid out intelligently, its super easy to type a bunch of dates and " services" into a spreadsheet. I can walk around a vehicle and reconcile certain repairs against a manual log.
There are real quick checks that tell me to keep looking or walk away - like add up all the oil changes and divide by mileage to determine a rough frequency of service.
UD
The point of my previous post was that while you and I appreciate meticulous records, the vast majority of the buying public could care less.