BMW B48 engine -5w40 ll 01 is ok ?

Messages
9
Location
Brazil - São Paulo
Thread starter
Hi guys First, Im from Brazil, sorry for my english I recently bought a 2015 Mini Cooper S with Bmw B48 engine Can i use 5w40 LL 01 approval in this engine or is better 5w30 ? I'm thinking about keep using shell hellix ultra 5w40 pureplus like my old 2013 beetle 2.0 tsi (Has good value in my country) I usually keep oil change interval at 6 months or 5.000 km - Because Heavy traffic and Poor gas quality. Im also considering motul 8100 but again it also 5w40 and way more expansive Here we dont have pennzol or liquimoly. If has any good recommendations for b48 engine, because i get the car last week and still dont know very well. Thanks!
 
Messages
9
Location
Brazil - São Paulo
Thread starter
Thanks for reply guys I will go with motul 8100 x-cees for now, it is twice of price shell helix ultra, but is superior and i think Worth pay more for better oil right ? If the cost keep high, i change to shell helix ultra.
 
Last edited:
Messages
10,257
Location
Colorado Springs
Originally Posted by Fabio_89
Thanks for reply guys I will go with motul 8100 x-cees for now, it is twice of price shell helix ultra, but is superior and i think Worth pay more for better oil right ? If the cost keep high, i change to shell helix ultra.
Not sure it i superior. Shell Helix is one of the most advance oils in the world. Both have same manufacturers approvals. Do not hang on base oils, and marketing (100% synthetic). It is final result that matters, and take into consideration that Shell supplies oils for BMW's.
 
Messages
9
Location
Brazil - São Paulo
Thread starter
Originally Posted by edyvw
Not sure it i superior. Shell Helix is one of the most advance oils in the world. Both have same manufacturers approvals. Do not hang on base oils, and marketing (100% synthetic). It is final result that matters, and take into consideration that Shell supplies oils for BMW's.
Thanks! So, now no doubt i will go shell helix ultra um next oil change!
Originally Posted by Nickdfresh
Pennzoil is probably very similar to Helix if not identical at this point...
Thanks, but we dont have pennzoil here in Brazil
 
Messages
10,257
Location
Colorado Springs
Originally Posted by Fabio_89
Originally Posted by edyvw
Not sure it i superior. Shell Helix is one of the most advance oils in the world. Both have same manufacturers approvals. Do not hang on base oils, and marketing (100% synthetic). It is final result that matters, and take into consideration that Shell supplies oils for BMW's.
Thanks! So, now no doubt i will go shell helix ultra um next oil change!
Originally Posted by Nickdfresh
Pennzoil is probably very similar to Helix if not identical at this point...
Thanks, but we dont have pennzoil here in Brazil
Pennzoil is Shell. Shell uses Pennzoil name in the US because it is more recognizable.
 
Messages
9
Location
Brazil - São Paulo
Thread starter
Originally Posted by edyvw
Originally Posted by Fabio_89
Originally Posted by edyvw
Not sure it i superior. Shell Helix is one of the most advance oils in the world. Both have same manufacturers approvals. Do not hang on base oils, and marketing (100% synthetic). It is final result that matters, and take into consideration that Shell supplies oils for BMW's.
Thanks! So, now no doubt i will go shell helix ultra um next oil change!
Originally Posted by Nickdfresh
Pennzoil is probably very similar to Helix if not identical at this point...
Thanks, but we dont have pennzoil here in Brazil
Pennzoil is Shell. Shell uses Pennzoil name in the US because it is more recognizable.
I didn't know ! Thanks
 
Messages
6,065
Location
KY
Originally Posted by Fabio_89
Thanks for reply guys I will go with motul 8100 x-cees for now, it is twice of price shell helix ultra, but is superior and i think Worth pay more for better oil right ? If the cost keep high, i change to shell helix ultra.
Motul is not a bad oil, but as I stated above, ANY LL-01 rated oil will work fine. I would go with Shell Helix as it is an excellent oil and has LL-01 approval. The fact that it costs 50% less than Motul is just icing on the cake. I seriously doubt that Motul oil is a significantly better oil than Shell Helix, and it definitely isn't twice as good.
 
Messages
5,180
Location
Paramount, California
Originally Posted by Fabio_89
Thanks for reply guys I will go with motul 8100 x-cees for now, it is twice of price shell helix ultra, but is superior and i think Worth pay more for better oil right ? If the cost keep high, i change to shell helix ultra.
You're making a mistake. Motul 8100 X-cess 5W-40 is a cheap Group III oil. Shell Helix Ultra with PurePlus is a premium GTL oil. You're paying twice for an oil made from cheaper base stocks than for an oil with premium base stocks. Also, within a given OEM category, such as BMW LL-01, an oil with a smaller x and/or smaller y in xW-y will use a more premium base oil because it's harder to make an oil when x gets smaller (to meet the CCS and NOACK requirements simultaneously) or y gets smaller (to meet the HTHSV requirement). So, a 5W-30 LL-01 oil would be more premium than a 5W-40 and a 0W-30 LL-01 oil would be more premium than a 5W-30. A more premium oil lasts longer and cleans the engine better. You also benefit from increased fuel economy and smoother-running engine.
 
Messages
9
Location
Brazil - São Paulo
Thread starter
Hi I need help once again I was using Shell Helix Ultra 5w40 on my BMW B48 engine, but it seens that Helix Ultra lost BMW LL-01 approval !! What another oil can i go from Motul, Mobil, Castrol, Pentosin with same quality?? (Brazil Market is very limited of oil's brand ) Thanks
 
Messages
15,014
Location
Upper Midwest
Anything with Longlife-04 approval, or anything with either Mercedes-Benz 229.5 or Porsche A40 approval. Just keep using the Helix that is very good oil and forget about Longlife-01, that approval is being phased out apparently.
 
Messages
9
Location
Brazil - São Paulo
Thread starter
Originally Posted by kschachn
Anything with Longlife-04 approval, or anything with either Mercedes-Benz 229.5 or Porsche A40 approval. Just keep using the Helix that is very good oil and forget about Longlife-01, that approval is being phased out apparently.
Ok, i will keep it ! Thanks
 
Messages
114
Location
San Diego, CA
Originally Posted by Gokhan
Originally Posted by Fabio_89
Thanks for reply guys I will go with motul 8100 x-cees for now, it is twice of price shell helix ultra, but is superior and i think Worth pay more for better oil right ? If the cost keep high, i change to shell helix ultra.
You're making a mistake. Motul 8100 X-cess 5W-40 is a cheap Group III oil. Shell Helix Ultra with PurePlus is a premium GTL oil. You're paying twice for an oil made from cheaper base stocks than for an oil with premium base stocks. Also, within a given OEM category, such as BMW LL-01, an oil with a smaller x and/or smaller y in xW-y will use a more premium base oil because it's harder to make an oil when x gets smaller (to meet the CCS and NOACK requirements simultaneously) or y gets smaller (to meet the HTHSV requirement). So, a 5W-30 LL-01 oil would be more premium than a 5W-40 and a 0W-30 LL-01 oil would be more premium than a 5W-30. A more premium oil lasts longer and cleans the engine better. You also benefit from increased fuel economy and smoother-running engine.
Interesting. You're the first I've read that says that Motul oil is inferior.
 
Top