Recent Topics
Kia oil control valve
by Propflux01
10/31/14 10:16 PM
Avalanche power steering cooler
by spasm3
10/31/14 09:58 PM
Sharp 42" LED 1080p/120Hz - $299
by mrsilv04
10/31/14 09:50 PM
brake squeak left turn.
by wrcsixeight
10/31/14 09:40 PM
Sgt. Tamoressi released
by FL_Rob
10/31/14 09:09 PM
Castrol Magnatec PDS.
by HappyLittlePony
10/31/14 08:29 PM
snowblower 5w20 wt oil
by subaroo
10/31/14 08:02 PM
Duralube
by bobbob
10/31/14 07:07 PM
Load Test Battery with Min/Max Function
by Merkava_4
10/31/14 07:07 PM
17 years. Zero trick or treaters.
by simple_gifts
10/31/14 07:06 PM
found a firearm I'd forgot I owned-
by Lapham3
10/31/14 06:31 PM
Furnace flame sensor?
by mrsilv04
10/31/14 06:15 PM
Newest Members
joyridin83, NH73, Blkflg, steam_soldier, Ben_SC
51763 Registered Users
Who's Online
76 registered (abycat, 147_Grain, 901Memphis, aquariuscsm, 77GrandPrix, 7 invisible), 1168 Guests and 194 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
51761 Members
64 Forums
221494 Topics
3502653 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG

Topic Options
#9739 - 11/09/02 07:54 AM Synthetic Oil vs API Service SL ILSAC GF 3
jsleesi Offline


Registered: 10/07/02
Posts: 22
Loc: Seattle, Washington
According to automobile technical information, the API Service SL ILSAC GF-3 is equally good oil as Synthetic oil????
If it is the case, why spend extra money on the oil? Can some one explain the pros and cons on the two types of oil?

Thanks

Top
#9740 - 11/09/02 02:24 PM Re: Synthetic Oil vs API Service SL ILSAC GF 3
Patman Offline



Registered: 05/27/02
Posts: 19287
Loc: Oakville, Ontario
I'm a bit confused as to what you are asking because synthetics are also classified under the API SL and ILSAC GF3 regulations too.

The dino oil may have just barely passed the tests, while the synthetic could be considerably above it.

Top
#9741 - 11/09/02 03:43 PM Re: Synthetic Oil vs API Service SL ILSAC GF 3
widman Offline


Registered: 05/27/02
Posts: 3071
Loc: Bolivia
if you read through all the threads on this board you will probably come to the conclusion that the SL oils are all very good, much better than others, with performance within the category improving as you increase the quality of the base oil (Group I to II, II to II+, II+ to III, and III to group IV & V blends; and lower the quantity of the VI improvers. Thus, one of the biggest advantages to group IV/V synthetics is in it's almost total lack of ability to shear down, and it's better pumpability at low temps.

Top
#9742 - 11/09/02 03:54 PM Re: Synthetic Oil vs API Service SL ILSAC GF 3
Pablo Offline


Registered: 10/28/02
Posts: 46694
Loc: Duvall WA - Pacific NW USA
quote:
According to automobile technical information, the API Service SL ILSAC GF-3 is equally good oil as Synthetic oil????

[I dont know] I thinks we needs to see this " techinical information" you are talking about. While I think it is the underlying goal of API to improve motor oil with each revision, I think some nomenclature, middle logic and data got lost in translation here. As pointed out, synthetic oils can be SL as well.....API tests are just a minimum gate to pass.

[ November 10, 2002, 07:55 AM: Message edited by: Pablo ]

Top
#9743 - 11/10/02 06:05 AM Re: Synthetic Oil vs API Service SL ILSAC GF 3
impala_sc Offline


Registered: 10/02/02
Posts: 25
Loc: South Carolina
perhaps they were referring to the fuel economy test? The ILSAC fuel economy tests compare an ILSAC GF3 candidate to a certain PAO oil.

Top
#9744 - 11/10/02 10:12 PM Re: Synthetic Oil vs API Service SL ILSAC GF 3
Eiron Offline


Registered: 09/25/02
Posts: 951
Loc: Loveland, Colorado
quote:
Originally posted by impala_sc:
The ILSAC fuel economy tests compare an ILSAC GF3 candidate to a certain PAO oil.

I believe the Base Comparison oil is an oil which does NOT meet ILSAC specs. Both GF-2 & GF-3 specs require an *improvement* in fuel efficiency over the base oil.

jsleesi,
You're paying extra for even more durability. Yes, all GF-3/SL oils will be far superior to what was previously available, & if you can't get past the 3mo/3k mi change mentality, any SL oil is fantastic. Keep in mind that ILSAC tests are run for "normal" oil durations; their longest test is for 96 hrs, which is 2k-3k mi for me. I run my oil 3 to 5 times that, & the extra durability I get from ANY premium oil means:
1) I get better protection at the beginning of the oil's life
2) I get equal/better protection at the end of the oil's life
3) I spend less money overall
4) I spend less time changing oil
5) I dump out less oil (recycle, but it's still waste)
6) I get more cookies & beer 'cuz "all of the above"

Jeez... okay, now I can't get past #6 [Duh!]

What's the specific application/duration you're using it in?

Top
#9745 - 11/12/02 07:46 AM Re: Synthetic Oil vs API Service SL ILSAC GF 3
impala_sc Offline


Registered: 10/02/02
Posts: 25
Loc: South Carolina
quote:
I believe the Base Comparison oil is an oil which does NOT meet ILSAC specs.
Correct. But the base comparison oil for the economy test is, I think, a PAO oil. That way the DINO ILSAC GF3 marketers could claim their oil "outperforms synthetic" aka PAO as long as they don't say how.

Top