Recent Topics
Could this be as good as last year?
by John_K
04/24/14 01:47 PM
Road trip to Palo Duro Canyon?
by Benzadmiral
04/24/14 12:42 PM
Pork Brine!
by 123Saab
04/24/14 09:57 AM
Water in Gas
by outoforder
04/24/14 09:12 AM
Valve job pics
by Stelth
04/24/14 09:01 AM
2000 Yamaha V-Star Mobil Delvac 15w40 @ 3000 miles
by outoforder
04/24/14 08:58 AM
Adding SSD to a 6-year-old desktop?
by Quattro Pete
04/24/14 08:37 AM
Laptop hard drive
by Oldmoparguy1
04/24/14 08:11 AM
carquest 5w30 full synthetic
by waltywalt
04/24/14 08:03 AM
Summer Car - start up
by 2stroker
04/24/14 07:59 AM
Small engine, PCMO or HDEO?
by supercity
04/24/14 06:50 AM
please explain twin hammer vs twin clutch impacts
by Donald
04/24/14 06:49 AM
Newest Members
2stroker, BMWR1200GS, Npeters1205, shrekulo, Helpme
49680 Registered Users
Who's Online
91 registered (90crvtec, 99Saturn, 440Magnum, 901Memphis, actionstan, 123Saab, 8 invisible), 2068 Guests and 181 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
49680 Members
64 Forums
212360 Topics
3329125 Posts

Max Online: 2651 @ 04/21/14 04:38 PM
Donate to BITOG

Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#496709 - 05/16/06 12:47 AM TG vs. Pure1
schwartr88 Offline


Registered: 01/20/06
Posts: 486
Loc: Morrice, MI
Does anyone have proof/statements/hypothesis/theories, or anyother evidence as to what filter is better between the fram tough guard and pureone air filter.

Or perhaps they are equal.

Top
#496710 - 05/16/06 01:25 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
UncleS2 Offline


Registered: 05/27/02
Posts: 2960
Loc: Far North East Texas
I don't.(that was helpful, huh? [Big Grin] ) I can only read the ads like everyone else.

Both are oiled paper with (I think) some synthetic fiber in them. If all else is equal, I'd expect oiled paper to catch more cooties than dry paper. I'd expect similar performance from two oiled paper filters, & expect differences to be small- but that might be wrong in a big way. [I dont know]

Here's an idea- for about $20 + tax, you could buy one of each for your car & compare 'em. Count pleats, compare thickness & pliability of gaskets, how oily do they seem, smooth or fuzzy paper, etc. You'd then also have two perfectly good air filters for your car. You could even post pix here for us on BITOG! [Big Grin]

There's a sealed Pure One for my car on the shelf, & I just may get a Fram ToughGuard & try my own comparison. After posting this reply, looks like I'll be obligated to post pix too! [Cheers!]

Top
#496711 - 05/16/06 03:01 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
schwartr88 Offline


Registered: 01/20/06
Posts: 486
Loc: Morrice, MI
^^
I may do that, but right now I have 3 TG in my shed right now, so it may be awhile before I get to try a P1.

One thing about the TG is the line of glue they have in the middle to keep the pleats uniform. So far I have used 2 and they seem decent, however, on the third one there was a ball of glue in the middle of 2 pleats causing a big gap. I removed the wad of glue but caused a small tear in the element.

Just one thing to consider.

Top
#496712 - 05/16/06 03:46 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
AstroVic Offline


Registered: 07/29/04
Posts: 671
Loc: Houston
Well, I don't know about performance, but I'd have to agree with Stuart Hughes ^^^ on this one. They're probably about the same.

I'll add this...

I don't buy ANYTHING from Fram simply based on the way they build crappy oil filters and then charge a premium price for them.

Purolator is a very reputable company on the other hand.

So, between the two, I'd drive out of my way to buy the Purolator. Fram products will never be found on any of my cars.

Top
#496713 - 05/26/06 06:11 PM Re: TG vs. Pure1
cristphoto Offline


Registered: 05/25/06
Posts: 51
Loc: Maryland
quote:
Originally posted by schwartr88:
Does anyone have proof/statements/hypothesis/theories, or anyother evidence as to what filter is better between the fram tough guard and pureone air filter.

Or perhaps they are equal.


Top
#496714 - 05/26/06 06:12 PM Re: TG vs. Pure1
cristphoto Offline


Registered: 05/25/06
Posts: 51
Loc: Maryland
quote:
Originally posted by schwartr88:
Does anyone have proof/statements/hypothesis/theories, or anyother evidence as to what filter is better between the fram tough guard and pureone air filter.

Or perhaps they are equal.


Top
#496715 - 05/26/06 06:15 PM Re: TG vs. Pure1
cristphoto Offline


Registered: 05/25/06
Posts: 51
Loc: Maryland
How about the NAPA Gold filters? They're available at all Napa dealers and on-line (where I got mine). I've seen reports where they have excellent filtration and a little better flow than stock paper elements. That's what I have and am happy. Steve

Top
#496716 - 05/27/06 12:48 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
vad Offline


Registered: 05/01/03
Posts: 1856
Loc: So Cal
It's all relative.
The Napa filters are not made by the same supplier.
The OEM filters differ in quality from brand to brand, and even within the same brand, since different car models would often get the OEM filters sourced from different suppliers.
You can not make a blanket statement like the brand X filters are better than brand Y, because of rebranding and supplier changes.
There are few exceptions when you move up in price and get the filters made with premium media quality as found in the Amsoil Ea and Purolator PureOne.
In those cases you know exactly what you get.

Top
#496717 - 05/28/06 03:48 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
vad Offline


Registered: 05/01/03
Posts: 1856
Loc: So Cal
BTW, the PureOne and the Fram TG are only available for very few models.

Top
#496718 - 05/28/06 08:21 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
01rangerxl Offline


Registered: 04/08/06
Posts: 6946
Loc: Birmingham, AL
quote:
Originally posted by AstroVic:
Purolator is a very reputable company on the other hand.

So, between the two, I'd drive out of my way to buy the Purolator. Fram products will never be found on any of my cars.

Purolator is not perfect either. A little over a year ago I purchased a regular Purolator air filter for my truck. I did not open the box to look at the filter because I assumed that a company could not screw up something as simple as a paper filter. Purolator did. The gasket was extremely thin and as a result the air filter housing would not seal (the top would move around).

A couple months ago I decided to give Purolator a chance again and bought a PureOne. The fit is better than the regular Purolator I had bought before, but it could still use some work. If the filter is not centered, the edge can get pushed into the housing. Also, though the gasket seems to seal the filter housing good enough, it is not quite as thick as I would like. The Fram and STP air filters I have bought before all had thicker gaskets and a more snug fit in the filter housing. The PureOne does do a very good job at filtering. It has trapped more dirt in 5,000 miles than regular ones do in 10,000+. I just wish the gasket was better.

And no, I don't use Fram oil filters. Never have and never will (unless they can compete at all with Motorcraft). I will use their air filters though.

Top
#496719 - 05/28/06 11:57 PM Re: TG vs. Pure1
another Todd Offline


Registered: 05/15/06
Posts: 1503
Loc: Southern CA
I recently ordered through the i-net pure one air filters for three of my four vehicles. I got them from the online division of Kragen, which is at partsamerica.com. They had all the one's I wanted. Couldn't find any locally. When they arrived, a good inspection gave me the impression of a high quality filter. I held them up to the sun and looked through the media and saw no "rays of light" indicating a pin hole in the media. The fram extra guard had such holes. The gasket or rubber sealing material seemed thick and more pliable/flexible than the fram, and I think it would seal better. I have installed two of them and the fit snugger into the housing that the filters I took out. My opinion is that they are an overall better filter, and well worth the price! Some of these filters are only a couple bucks more than their regular filter. good luck. todd

Top
#496720 - 05/29/06 05:12 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
vad Offline


Registered: 05/01/03
Posts: 1856
Loc: So Cal
[Welcome!] [Cheers!]

Top
#496721 - 06/01/06 04:54 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
another Todd Offline


Registered: 05/15/06
Posts: 1503
Loc: Southern CA
Thanks!

Top
#496722 - 06/27/06 02:12 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
01rangerxl Offline


Registered: 04/08/06
Posts: 6946
Loc: Birmingham, AL
Today I replaced the PureOne I was using with a Fram Tough Guard. I had removed the PureOne to see how dirty it was and it felt suprisingly "limp" for lack of a better term. It was very easy to bend and I didn't really feel comfortable keeping it in the truck. It has been exposed to a fair amount of humidity, but I have not had another filter bend as much as it did before.

I like the construction of the Tough Guard more. It has lines of glue running across the pleats to keep them in place. It also has a slightly thicker gasket than the PureOne. The air filter housing seemed to shut more securely with the Tough Guard. In addition to the better construction, it was about $6 cheaper than the PureOne (only about $10 for my application at Wal-Mart).

I will say that the Pure One trapped a lot more dirt than the plain paper filters I had been using. I think the media itself is very good at filtering, I'm just not 100% satisfied with the overall construction.

BTW - I'm not normally a fan of Fram, and I use Motorcraft (Purolator) oil filters exclusively, but air filters are another story.

Top
#496723 - 06/27/06 06:22 AM Re: TG vs. Pure1
schwartr88 Offline


Registered: 01/20/06
Posts: 486
Loc: Morrice, MI
Besides being 3-9 dollars cheaper, the toughguard is more ridgid and has about 15 more pleats in it than the PureOne does for my truck. However, the P1 does seem to have more oil on it.

Ill stick with the fram tough guard, Ive been using their air filters for years and never had a problem.

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >