Recent Topics
Moving away from HM oil: safe to do?
by zuluplus30
01/26/15 11:44 PM
2 officers shot in MN
by KD0AXS
01/26/15 10:29 PM
Is Beck Arnley Coolant Really That Good?
by BHopkins
01/26/15 09:54 PM
Company vehicles, anybody beat on theirs?
by slowdime
01/26/15 09:45 PM
Hyundai Accent 2003 ATF recommendations?
by joel96
01/26/15 08:48 PM
Castrol Edge 5 qt jugs for $21.66 at Wally World
by teddyboy
01/26/15 08:26 PM
Bulk Castrol Syntorq at Midwest Transmission Centr
by LEIBUYS
01/26/15 08:24 PM
time based oil changes?
by NH73
01/26/15 08:22 PM
Container truck backed over our Navigator's hood
by DoubleWasp
01/26/15 07:45 PM
posting pictures?
by Jehu
01/26/15 07:30 PM
Real Pizzas
by Pop_Rivit
01/26/15 07:17 PM
Filter suggestion for a long-ish interval
by slowdime
01/26/15 06:19 PM
Newest Members
fordspot, AjHockett, tm0787, CharlieNovak, caskab
52618 Registered Users
Who's Online
68 registered (addyguy, another Todd, 2010_FX4, 2004tdigls, 4 invisible), 1011 Guests and 147 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
52618 Members
66 Forums
225621 Topics
3589543 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG
Topic Options
#3734 - 07/28/02 07:51 PM Is this a good way to rate oil?
The_Oz Offline


Registered: 07/24/02
Posts: 349
Loc: Quebec, Canada
Hey Guys,

Found some interesting reading outside these boards. What is the viability of GM 4718 and CH-4 approved oils on Gasoline engines? Yes, meeting API SL specs is very easy and it is not really a good way of judging oil.

Just curious because there is very few oils that I see that actually mention these test approvals.

Regards,

Oz

Top
#3735 - 07/31/02 07:43 PM Re: Is this a good way to rate oil?
Dick in Falls Church Offline


Registered: 06/01/02
Posts: 1406
Loc: Falls Church VA
CH-4 is a diesel spec--not really pertinent to use in gas engines.

The GM 4718 spec, best I recall, came out when GM started putting Mobil 1 into Corvettes--and, best I know, requires a synthetic to meet it.

Top
#3736 - 07/31/02 08:45 PM Re: Is this a good way to rate oil?
The_Oz Offline


Registered: 07/24/02
Posts: 349
Loc: Quebec, Canada
Yes, I know CH-4 is primarily used in the Diesel group. However, since most Diesel oils that I've seen are Sx licensed (Mobil Delvac 1, AMSOIL 3000, Shell Rotella, Petro Canada Duron, etc.), I'd figure the Cx standards are far more rigorous since most Sx oils are only rated up to CF in the commercial ratings dept. And CH-4 rated oils typically have SJ or SH ratings. This is what I need confirmation on...I guess [I dont know]

Regards,

Oz

Top
#3737 - 08/01/02 09:24 AM Re: Is this a good way to rate oil?
jjbula Offline


Registered: 07/04/02
Posts: 479
Loc: Montgomery, AL
European ACEA A-3 standard seems to be slightly better than SL.
The A3 spec I like is the HTHS >3.5.
The jury is still out on the necessity of this parameter,
but it indicates better hydrodynamic lubrication at high temp.
Xw30 oils have trouble meeting A3 Xw40 oils only meet it if they are 0w40 or 5w40 (fuel economy part of A3).

see link
http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/states%20of%20lubrication.html

If hydrodynamic lube is overcome then barrier or boundary layer lube is used.
For that I would look for an oil with good levels of ZDDP and Moly.
Mobil 1 is using less ZDDP but promises good protection with Super Syn

You probably know that, but that is what I've been searching for in wear protection.

[ August 01, 2002, 12:30 PM: Message edited by: jjbula ]

Top
#3738 - 08/01/02 09:53 AM Re: Is this a good way to rate oil?
jjbula Offline


Registered: 07/04/02
Posts: 479
Loc: Montgomery, AL
Do you know how GM 4718 might be superior to SL?

Top
#3739 - 07/31/02 10:47 PM Re: Is this a good way to rate oil?
The_Oz Offline


Registered: 07/24/02
Posts: 349
Loc: Quebec, Canada
quote:
Do you know how GM 4718 might be superior to SL?
Actually jjbula, I have no clue as to what this certification is all about [Confused] All I know about GM4718 is that it was to meet certain specifications for Corvette engines. Exactly what specs, I don't know either.

Want to explain this to me?

Thanks,

Oz

Top