Recent Topics
soft varnish/sludge on oil fill baffle Toy 2GR-FE
by friendly_jacek
10/25/14 11:06 PM
F1 - 2014 United States Grand Prix
by gofast182
10/25/14 10:48 PM
Humor: Walmart Product Review
by Apollo14
10/25/14 10:04 PM
Mobil Delvac 5w-40 OK for 2009 Audi Q7 TDI?
by teedoff00
10/25/14 10:02 PM
Honda S2000 Pennzoil Ultra 5,000 miles
by Bror Jace
10/25/14 09:52 PM
Time for hot vs cold old to drain into pan
by Apollo14
10/25/14 09:19 PM
Noco Genius Boost - my video test - battery @ 9.9v
by 901Memphis
10/25/14 09:13 PM
Bought my first firearm today
by Nick R
10/25/14 09:01 PM
Built a few AR-15 A3's this weekend...
by 2010_FX4
10/25/14 08:57 PM
New Briggs oiling schedule
by Tom_T
10/25/14 08:52 PM
Thinking about a new 1.0L Ecoboost Fiesta
by Burt
10/25/14 08:44 PM
Viscosity Calculators don't work well below zero..
by Shannow
10/25/14 08:12 PM
Newest Members
after5hock, Rxman01, 1969monark, flstang65, PhxAZ
51699 Registered Users
Who's Online
92 registered (340_Magnum, 901Memphis, 67lemans, 2010_FX4, 05LGTLtd, 11 invisible), 1074 Guests and 235 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
51699 Members
64 Forums
221214 Topics
3497557 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG

Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#2758899 - 09/30/12 03:03 PM Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614
k1rod Offline


Registered: 12/17/06
Posts: 265
Loc: Arizona
After seeing DirtRacers post showing a cut open Fram Tough Guard filter, I decided I couldn't trust the one I had in the stash so I cut it open too.
I didn't see the major QC problems DirtRacer found with his but it certainly isn't IMHO a top shelf filter. Here Are the photos:



This photo shows how off centered the cardboard endcaps are on the filtering media.


I have no idea what these discolored splotches are...


Showing some very uneven pleats.


Angle View.

Everything looked glued correctly and I didn't see any paths for oil bypass but nothing special here either. The center tube was round,
the ADV looked good, the filter was functional. I guess if I were characterize this, I would say it just looks like there is no "pride of workmanship" here.


Edited by k1rod (09/30/12 03:11 PM)

Top
#2758918 - 09/30/12 03:38 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
pbm Offline


Registered: 04/19/04
Posts: 5254
Loc: New York
I had no problem with that filter (cardboard end-caps) until I saw the huge pleat spacing in the last two photos.....that's terrible quality control. That spacing alone would take these filters off my list....

Top
#2758923 - 09/30/12 03:47 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
NHGUY Offline


Registered: 10/09/11
Posts: 3381
Loc: USA
If only Fram came in clear housings,I dont think anyone would buy one.Wonder how bad their drop in elements look?

Top
#2758927 - 09/30/12 03:54 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
cp3 Offline


Registered: 07/26/06
Posts: 2614
Loc: Kitchener, Ontario, Canada
Well, another disappointment. I guess maybe I got lucky with the TG3387A I used, looked better than either this or DirtRacer's.

Thanx to both for the pics!
_________________________
Dodge Charger|Pennzoil Platinum 5w20|Mopar MO-744
Pontiac G6 GT|Mobil 1 0w40|Mobil 1 M1-101

Top
#2758928 - 09/30/12 03:56 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: NHGUY]
cp3 Offline


Registered: 07/26/06
Posts: 2614
Loc: Kitchener, Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: NHGUY
If only Fram came in clear housings,I dont think anyone would buy one.Wonder how bad their drop in elements look?


Cartridge filters don't look too bad at all. TG9018
_________________________
Dodge Charger|Pennzoil Platinum 5w20|Mopar MO-744
Pontiac G6 GT|Mobil 1 0w40|Mobil 1 M1-101

Top
#2758944 - 09/30/12 04:16 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
sayjac Offline


Registered: 10/13/08
Posts: 8230
Loc: The Old North State
Pleat spacing doesn't concern me, bypass design is fine imo as is the silicone adbv. And the tapping plate is the superior design. Biggest complaint again is the fiber endcap seemingly not extending beyond the centertube around the full diameter.

Thanks for the pics.

Top
#2758984 - 09/30/12 05:40 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
SS1970chrysler Offline


Registered: 05/01/11
Posts: 1322
Loc: PA
The only thing I see that would concern me is that the seam for the ends of the media strip aren't sealed together much if at all on this one. Last one I opened had a metal piece over the seam.
_________________________
93 Towncar- PYB 5w-30+M.Craft
63 Newport- Rotella 15w-40+Protec
78 LTD- S.Pro HD30+ProTec
62 LeSabre- Rotella 15w-40+Fram

Top
#2758998 - 09/30/12 05:54 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
DirtRacer53 Offline


Registered: 06/28/12
Posts: 119
Loc: South Central PA, US

What did I start? hornets

Btw, was one side of the filter element longer than the other


Edited by DirtRacer53 (09/30/12 05:56 PM)
_________________________
2005 Chevy Silverado 1500 4.3L
Current Fill: QSUD 5W-30
Fram TG3387A Oil Filter
Fram TGA8755A Air Filter

Top
#2759039 - 09/30/12 06:27 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
carwreck Offline


Registered: 04/04/09
Posts: 464
Loc: CT
Originally Posted By: k1rod
After seeing DirtRacers post showing a cut open Fram Tough Guard filter...
Showing some very uneven pleats.


The uneven pleats are just a result of the automated machine used to wrap the pleats around the core. (2:40-3:00 in video)
Fram orange can with black handgrip

Top
#2759059 - 09/30/12 06:47 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: carwreck]
cp3 Offline


Registered: 07/26/06
Posts: 2614
Loc: Kitchener, Ontario, Canada
Yes that is the reason for the uneven pleats but we have seen examples where that large spread has caused the media to fail. E-Core and Purolator Classic I believe they were. The spacing was wide enough to allow the pleat to fold down, the E-Core was blown through the center tube and the Classic ripped at the glue. Not a Fram only problem but one I would like to avoid if I can.

I also just realized the 3387 I linked to had the metal clip on the end seam of the media. Seems they have dropped that as well.
_________________________
Dodge Charger|Pennzoil Platinum 5w20|Mopar MO-744
Pontiac G6 GT|Mobil 1 0w40|Mobil 1 M1-101

Top
#2759090 - 09/30/12 07:11 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: DirtRacer53]
k1rod Offline


Registered: 12/17/06
Posts: 265
Loc: Arizona
Originally Posted By: DirtRacer53

What did I start? hornets

Btw, was one side of the filter element longer than the other


I'm glad you started it. This filter is priced at $6.99 most places putting it in the marketing category of a "premium" filter. I think it's good for us to investigate whether it is or isn't.

Was one side of the element longer? Not significantly. I measured the length (height) of the filter element at 90 degree intervals. The measurements were 2.40" @ 0 deg, 2.38 @ 90 deg, 2.38" @ 180 deg, 2.39" @ 270 deg. Max variance was 0.02". Not too bad.

Top
#2759203 - 09/30/12 08:50 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
dnewton3 Offline



Registered: 05/14/07
Posts: 5628
Loc: Indianapolis, IN
I was about ready to buy some TGs but now I'm second guessing them ...

In theory, they are fine. The fiber board does not really bother me the way it does some others. The ADBV is silicone; I like it. The can itself seems reasonable; I like that. The endplate seems well made. I like that.

But it seems like the quality control around the media and sub-structure suffers in reality.

A well designed product means nothing if manufacturing fails to produce what was the intent.


Edited by dnewton3 (09/30/12 08:51 PM)
_________________________
Conventionals vs. Synthetics isn't about which is "better"; it's about which lasts longer, while assuring safe operation, in relation to cost. Any product can be over or under utilized. The same applies to filters.
Make an informed decision; first consider your operating conditions, next determine your maintenance plan, and then pick your lube and filter. Don't do it the other way around ...

Top
#2759222 - 09/30/12 09:27 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: dnewton3]
k1rod Offline


Registered: 12/17/06
Posts: 265
Loc: Arizona
I think I'm exactly where you are 'dnewton". I think that this filter would have worked OK over a reasonable OCI, but that was just this particular filter. The sloppy looking QC standards applied to this filter make me seriously wonder if the next one I purchased would not be functional, much as the filter DirtRacer's is showing is not. You can not cut every filter open to see if the particular one you've got is good so that leaves you having to trust the manufacturer with the well being of our very expensive automobiles. From all I am seeing, Fram does not appear to merit that trust. JMHO.

Top
#2759701 - 10/01/12 12:14 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: k1rod]
edhackett Offline


Registered: 06/09/03
Posts: 1544
Loc: Sequim, WA
What do you guys mean that filter is "fine"? Look at the third picture again. The center tube is off center. This is a place for oil to bypass. These should have the center tube fully covered by the end caps so that the center tube provides a solid support for the end pieces to seal against.

Ed
_________________________
Never attribute to engineers that into which politicians, lawyers, accountants, and marketeers have poked their fingers.

Top
#2759723 - 10/01/12 12:46 PM Re: Another Fram Tough Guard Cut Open - TG3614 [Re: edhackett]
ZeeOSix Offline


Registered: 07/22/10
Posts: 7418
Loc: PNW
Originally Posted By: edhackett
What do you guys mean that filter is "fine"? Look at the third picture again. The center tube is off center. This is a place for oil to bypass. These should have the center tube fully covered by the end caps so that the center tube provides a solid support for the end pieces to seal against.

Ed


It should actually seal OK. You can see the ring impression on the end cap where the seal takes place. The ring located about 1/8~1/4" out from the center tube.

In the 2nd photo, is there a gap/hole through the media where the ends of the pleats attach to the end cap, or is that an optical illusion?

Overall, I don't like the construction of the FRAMs, except for the Ultra XG series.

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >