Recent Topics
Clicked over 300,000 miles today
by asand1
04/16/14 01:28 PM
2015 Hyundai Sonata
by opus1
04/16/14 01:07 PM
Gmail question
by Hokiefyd
04/16/14 12:32 PM
Asus Nexus7 Tablet Users?
by sleddriver
04/16/14 12:03 PM
WTH is this? Yahoo mail question
by 97tbird
04/16/14 11:39 AM
Install real-time lubrication oil quality sensor
by juliansb
04/16/14 11:37 AM
Identifying what motor an oil filter is used on
by graydog
04/16/14 11:24 AM
German Castrol in Accord calling for 5w20?
by kenpoed
04/16/14 11:07 AM
Pennzoil Platinum Low Viscosity Multi-Vehicle ATF
by Cooper
04/16/14 11:05 AM
Pennzoil Platinum CVT-2
by Cooper
04/16/14 11:02 AM
Industrial dual oil filter head
by OAS
04/16/14 10:53 AM
hyundai did a bg44 intake cleaning on my veloster
by waltywalt
04/16/14 10:51 AM
Newest Members
dwreefs, turbomond, buster26, WesleyG, MNLittle
49595 Registered Users
Who's Online
87 registered (anonobomber, 97tbird, 97f150, 77GrandPrix, Alex38, 4 invisible), 1951 Guests and 209 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
49595 Members
64 Forums
211954 Topics
3321765 Posts

Max Online: 2551 @ 04/05/14 01:28 PM
Donate to BITOG

Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#2020606 - 09/18/10 01:53 PM Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30?
The_Eric Offline


Registered: 03/31/10
Posts: 2892
Loc: Iowa
The other day, I was working on the boss to convert back to bulk oil, (from cases of quarts) citing environmental concerns and convenience. We briefly discussed what we'd stock and I suggested just having 5w-20 and 5w-30 in drums. Is there any concern using 5w-30 in place of a 10w-30? With today's modern base stocks and additive packages, I can't see why a 5w-30 wouldn't hold up in place of a 10w-30...

FWIW, the oil in question would be Kendall GT-1 Synthetic blend with the Liquid Titanium.

Top
#2020609 - 09/18/10 01:58 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30? [Re: The_Eric]
Spyder7 Offline


Registered: 07/28/10
Posts: 2269
Loc: NL, Canada
In Iowa 5W30 would be fine year round for any car using 10W30. I prefer 10W30 for mine, though 5W30 is fine for fall and winter, but that's only because it burns oil and the 10W30s I have are more resistant to burn off than their 5W30 counterparts (not due to thickness as both are the same at operating temp).

-Spyder
_________________________
2000 Corolla VE 118K km
Syntec 5W30 & QS filter



Top
#2020610 - 09/18/10 01:59 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30? [Re: The_Eric]
sangyup81 Offline


Registered: 10/24/09
Posts: 1645
Loc: Bowie, MD
I don't know about completely replacing 10w-30 since some customers may insist on it. Perhaps keep some in quart cases?

Practically, 10w-30 is better in cases where shear is a concern and for some direct injection applications but for the most part, 5w-30 shouldn't be a problem.
_________________________
00 Camry 122k/125k PeakSyn5w30 Bosch3311
03 Tribute V6 144k/146k MaxLife5w20 M1-210
10 Mazda3 36k/40k XOM10w30 FL300
10 Accord 10k/10k GTX5w20 Puro14610

Top
#2020611 - 09/18/10 01:59 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30? [Re: The_Eric]
Drew99GT Offline


Registered: 10/11/02
Posts: 20259
Loc: Colorado Springs
If you look at NOACK limits for SM/GF-4 compared to previous specs just a few years back (SH/GF-2), modern 5w-30 conventional oils would far surpass a 10w-30 of yesteryear. Given you'd be using The Kendall blend, I'd have no problem doing what you want to do. I bet the cost savings alone would be justifiable.


Edited by Drew99GT (09/18/10 02:00 PM)

Top
#2020669 - 09/18/10 03:41 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30? [Re: The_Eric]
mechtech2 Offline


Registered: 09/05/06
Posts: 19479
Loc: Chicago Area
I'd also go with the 5-30 instead.
10-30 is kinda obsolete.
Oils are tougher and more well built now. Shearing is rarely a real life concern.

Top
#2020697 - 09/18/10 04:11 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30? [Re: The_Eric]
The_Eric Offline


Registered: 03/31/10
Posts: 2892
Loc: Iowa
Great, thanks for your input! It more or less confirm my thoughts all along.

Now the tough part will be selling it to the boss. Granted it's not necessarily a bad thing, but if an oil cap calls for 10w-30 (like an older GM 3.8), then that's what goes in it unless it's winter time. Unless a customer asks for or supplies something different, it's strictly by the book/cap. The only thing is that some of those specs are outdated as many of you already know.


Edited by The_Eric (09/18/10 04:12 PM)

Top
#2020749 - 09/18/10 05:15 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30? [Re: mechtech2]
beast3300 Online   sleepy


Registered: 12/24/09
Posts: 2919
Loc: Ohio
Originally Posted By: mechtech2
I'd also go with the 5-30 instead.
10-30 is kinda obsolete.
Oils are tougher and more well built now. Shearing is rarely a real life concern.


agreed 100%
_________________________
'03 Regal GS L67: PU 5w30, P1 24011

'98 Regal GS: body scrapped.

'99 Grand Prix L36: Pennzoil Dexos blend 5w30/PF52E

Top
#2020758 - 09/18/10 05:26 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: The_Eric]
ItsuMitsubishi Offline


Registered: 06/14/10
Posts: 421
Loc: Ajax, ON
5w30 will hold up, but if you never even see freezing temps, what's the point? (Obviously not the pour point- flashpoint maybe) Unless you can be assured the 5w30 is formulated with a higher VI base stock than the 10w30, which can happen, why bother? Generally, I find most big oil blenders don't like to keep more basestock grades on hand than absolutely necessary, and 10w30 to be a more robust oil lacking only in VII content to it's 5w30 counterpart. There are a lot of old ways of thinking that are just obsolete these days, but honestly, 10w30 in warm climates is not one of them IMO.
_________________________
Winter Tires or Insurance Premium?
Irony is...

Top
#2020812 - 09/18/10 06:46 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: ItsuMitsubishi]
The_Eric Offline


Registered: 03/31/10
Posts: 2892
Loc: Iowa
Originally Posted By: ItsuMitsubishi
5w30 will hold up, but if you never even see freezing temps, what's the point? (Obviously not the pour point- flashpoint maybe) Unless you can be assured the 5w30 is formulated with a higher VI base stock than the 10w30, which can happen, why bother? Generally, I find most big oil blenders don't like to keep more basestock grades on hand than absolutely necessary, and 10w30 to be a more robust oil lacking only in VII content to it's 5w30 counterpart. There are a lot of old ways of thinking that are just obsolete these days, but honestly, 10w30 in warm climates is not one of them IMO.


First off, we definitely see freezing temps! Secondly, it'll be tough enough to get him to switch to 5w-30 for both applications, there's no way he'll go for 10w in a 5w application. I think he's one who doesn't know terribly much about oil, so 10w is thicker to him than 5w.

Top
#2020886 - 09/18/10 08:40 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: The_Eric]
ItsuMitsubishi Offline


Registered: 06/14/10
Posts: 421
Loc: Ajax, ON
Originally Posted By: The_Eric
Originally Posted By: ItsuMitsubishi
5w30 will hold up, but if you never even see freezing temps, what's the point? (Obviously not the pour point- flashpoint maybe) Unless you can be assured the 5w30 is formulated with a higher VI base stock than the 10w30, which can happen, why bother? Generally, I find most big oil blenders don't like to keep more basestock grades on hand than absolutely necessary, and 10w30 to be a more robust oil lacking only in VII content to it's 5w30 counterpart. There are a lot of old ways of thinking that are just obsolete these days, but honestly, 10w30 in warm climates is not one of them IMO.


First off, we definitely see freezing temps! Secondly, it'll be tough enough to get him to switch to 5w-30 for both applications, there's no way he'll go for 10w in a 5w application. I think he's one who doesn't know terribly much about oil, so 10w is thicker to him than 5w.


Whoops, yeah I checked your locale after I posted that. I thought it was for California or something. Indeed 5w is certainly the grade for your bud :)
_________________________
Winter Tires or Insurance Premium?
Irony is...

Top
#2020916 - 09/18/10 09:15 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: The_Eric]
The_Eric Offline


Registered: 03/31/10
Posts: 2892
Loc: Iowa
Gotcha. Thanks for your input.

Top
#2020945 - 09/18/10 09:59 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: The_Eric]
HTSS_TR Online   content


Registered: 04/17/06
Posts: 12148
Loc: Irvine, CA
Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 ?

Yes, the reason is Honda only specified 2 weights for S2000, for temp above 0F use only 10W30 and for temp below 0F use 5W40.

Why Honda recommend 5W40 in S2000, not 5W30, for temp below 0F is a mystery to me. For an engine that can rev to 9k RPM, 10W30 is more shear stable therefore it is recommended.
_________________________
'94 LS400
'00 E430
'04 S2000
"Consumerism has accustomed us to waste. But throwing food away is like stealing it from the poor and hungry" Pop Francis

Top
#3060016 - 07/09/13 09:25 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: HTSS_TR]
randomhero439 Offline


Registered: 07/21/12
Posts: 1245
Loc: ohio
Originally Posted By: HTSS_TR
Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 ?

Yes, the reason is Honda only specified 2 weights for S2000, for temp above 0F use only 10W30 and for temp below 0F use 5W40.

Why Honda recommend 5W40 in S2000, not 5W30, for temp below 0F is a mystery to me. For an engine that can rev to 9k RPM, 10W30 is more shear stable therefore it is recommended.


Bump: Honda needs the car to perform and rev like crazy in sub 0* temps too! The car requires a shear stable oil at lower temps. 10w-30 is not adequate for cold temps. 5w-30 is not shear stable enough. So 5w-40 works with cold temps, shear stable since its synthetic and is thicker to deal with the fuel dilution that winter driving creates.

Smart decision Honda.
_________________________
04 Accord EX V6 J30A4 6-speed MT: Pennzoil Ultra 5w-20 / PureONE
02 Civic LX I4 D17A1 5-speed MT: Pennzoil 10w-40 / Classic

Top
#3060027 - 07/09/13 09:33 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: The_Eric]
901Memphis Offline


Registered: 08/14/10
Posts: 3573
Loc: Northern Kentucky
Even since this thread was made in 2010 I'm sure 5w30s are even more shear resistant than before.
_________________________
'99 Ford Taurus 145k (Vulcan v6) - Current Fill = M1 HM 5w30 | FL400S
'02 Buick Century 98k (3.1 v6)- PU 5w30 / Fram Ultra XG 3980 / Filter mag

Top
#3060083 - 07/09/13 10:23 PM Re: Any reason not to use 5w-30 in place of 10w-30 [Re: 901Memphis]
randomhero439 Offline


Registered: 07/21/12
Posts: 1245
Loc: ohio
Originally Posted By: 901Memphis
Even since this thread was made in 2010 I'm sure 5w30s are even more shear resistant than before.


I agree, you could also argue that 5w-30 has come along way since the S2000 came out in 1999 wink
_________________________
04 Accord EX V6 J30A4 6-speed MT: Pennzoil Ultra 5w-20 / PureONE
02 Civic LX I4 D17A1 5-speed MT: Pennzoil 10w-40 / Classic

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >