Recent Topics
Cut Open - Toyota 90915 = yzzf2
by JC1
49 minutes 49 seconds ago
Cut Open - Purolator Classic L20195
by JC1
51 minutes 16 seconds ago
Cut Open - Purolator Pure One PL20195
by JC1
52 minutes 48 seconds ago
Cut Open - Napa Gold 1516
by JC1
53 minutes 34 seconds ago
Cut Open - Napa Gold 1334
by JC1
54 minutes 26 seconds ago
Carbon Fibre Trim
by domer10
56 minutes 21 seconds ago
Bosch D+ D3334 Cut Open
by Bookmaker
Today at 08:11 PM
2000 Chevy Astro Issues 2WD
by actionstan
Today at 08:07 PM
What ingredient makes it "Death"-Cool?
by Nayov
Today at 08:06 PM
Moving, BITOG style...
by 01rangerxl
Today at 07:51 PM
Bosch D+ D3410 Cut Open
by Bookmaker
Today at 07:39 PM
Good Alternative to Suzuki Super Grease "A"
by ABCarr
Today at 07:34 PM
Newest Members
BMWR1200GS, Npeters1205, shrekulo, Helpme, and111
49679 Registered Users
Who's Online
114 registered (b1amgm47, asand1, 72te27, 2010_FX4, 77GrandPrix, 12 invisible), 2128 Guests and 172 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
49679 Members
64 Forums
212341 Topics
3328625 Posts

Max Online: 2651 @ 04/21/14 04:38 PM
Donate to BITOG

Topic Options
#1974096 - 08/03/10 09:56 AM Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal
RamFan Offline


Registered: 05/09/10
Posts: 1520
Loc: Illinois, U.S.A
I've noticed that many people advise HDEO for cleaning up a sludgd engine, however if the engine is sludged up why would someone want to use a thick oil? I understand the high detergents of HDEO make it great for cleaning but wouldn't the oil thickness increase the possibility of clogging a passageway? Just a thought...
_________________________
06 Monte Carlo LT
+3.9l V6 - 142k - Havoline HM 5w30 - Security - OLM
14 CX-5 Grand Touring AWD
+2.5l I4 - 15k - Havoline 0w20 - Security - 6k/6mo

Top
#1974109 - 08/03/10 10:17 AM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: RamFan]
Gary Allan Offline


Registered: 09/28/02
Posts: 39806
Loc: Pottstown, PA
At temperature any oil will be thin enough. I think it's more the impression that a "thin" oil (keeping in mind our propensity to judge stuff at room temp) will sling around and perform scrubbing bubbles action better than one "less thin".

We tend to have vivid imaginations. I'm not saying that I'm exempt from those notions.
_________________________
http://lube-direct.com/gallan/

Top
#1974116 - 08/03/10 10:22 AM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: Gary Allan]
Steve S Offline


Registered: 01/20/03
Posts: 18449
Loc: East of IGO
The sludge itself is what causes the clogging not the oil.
_________________________
Why do people post I want the best for my car,,, When there isn't anything that is the best on the car to begin with.

Top
#1974121 - 08/03/10 10:26 AM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: Steve S]
RamFan Offline


Registered: 05/09/10
Posts: 1520
Loc: Illinois, U.S.A
I'm aware of that, I was saying that the loosened sludge in conjunction with the thicker oil could make it harder for the sludge to move through the system without getting stuck any where. However I think Gary's "sling around" theory is right, I'm imagining a thicker oil remaining more uniform therefore making it harder to move around an obstruction (stuck sludge) therefore a thinner oil would be more ideal since it would have a bigger probability of moving around the obstruction and continuing to move throughout the engine.
_________________________
06 Monte Carlo LT
+3.9l V6 - 142k - Havoline HM 5w30 - Security - OLM
14 CX-5 Grand Touring AWD
+2.5l I4 - 15k - Havoline 0w20 - Security - 6k/6mo

Top
#1974326 - 08/03/10 01:11 PM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: RamFan]
Lethal1ty17 Offline


Registered: 07/01/10
Posts: 675
Loc: Georgia
most people when trying to flush their engines use a thicker oil because they also use a thinner product like MMO or seafoam that lowers the overall viscosity of the oil thus thinning it out.

Top
#1974425 - 08/03/10 02:21 PM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: Lethal1ty17]
meep Offline


Registered: 02/20/07
Posts: 2398
Loc: Southeast
splashing around... a lighter vis oil will splatter off the sludge with less specific impact as the droplet deforms, than a heavier oil.

we could debate this for days...

I've never seen oil do any significant sludge removal, even with seafoam, etc.. screwdriver and a shop-vac, OTOH...

M
_________________________
2006 Tundra 2wd
2002 MDX (wifey!)
2003 town and country, in various state of repair

Top
#1974507 - 08/03/10 03:16 PM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: meep]
Spyder7 Offline


Registered: 07/28/10
Posts: 2269
Loc: NL, Canada
It could be debated for days, but its an interesting debate. And potentially informative.

-Spyder
_________________________
2000 Corolla VE 118K km
Syntec 5W30 & QS filter



Top
#1974620 - 08/03/10 04:31 PM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: Spyder7]
Lethal1ty17 Offline


Registered: 07/01/10
Posts: 675
Loc: Georgia
its not like the splattering oil under a valve cover really has much energy at all anyways. thin vs thick for cleaning the valve cover is negligable. the solvents are what really does the work.

Top
#1974643 - 08/03/10 04:50 PM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: Lethal1ty17]
jstutz Offline


Registered: 10/06/08
Posts: 1472
Loc: NC
I tend to like the thinner ones for cleaning up sludge. My thought is that if the sludge does dissolve into the oil, the oil will most likely thicker as it holds the sludge particles.

Top
#1974654 - 08/03/10 05:04 PM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: RamFan]
HangerHarley Offline


Registered: 06/10/10
Posts: 1239
Loc: Duval Co. Jax FL, USA
I too have given this some thought, and i have to narrowly vote THIN.

Reasoning:

If Oil passages are sludged up, let us just say that they are.. a Thin oil SHOULD flow through it BETTER than a Thick one. HDEO T5 Rotella will then make it bigger and bigger, and look for Blackening of the Oil and change Filter and also Oil every 1000 miles if it is working. But Keep on putting Rotella T5 in; MMO if you must. SeaFoam? Maybe before the change. MAYBE.

If you use a Thicker oil, you are basically just thinking it will plunge itself out.

So, id narrowly say, "Thin."

Rotella T5 is 15W-40 anyways, so its right in the middle of thin vs thick.

Top
#1975189 - 08/04/10 06:15 AM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: HangerHarley]
RamFan Offline


Registered: 05/09/10
Posts: 1520
Loc: Illinois, U.S.A
Originally Posted By: HangerHarley
I too have given this some thought, and i have to narrowly vote THIN.

Reasoning:

If Oil passages are sludged up, let us just say that they are.. a Thin oil SHOULD flow through it BETTER than a Thick one. HDEO T5 Rotella will then make it bigger and bigger, and look for Blackening of the Oil and change Filter and also Oil every 1000 miles if it is working. But Keep on putting Rotella T5 in; MMO if you must. SeaFoam? Maybe before the change. MAYBE.

If you use a Thicker oil, you are basically just thinking it will plunge itself out.

So, id narrowly say, "Thin."

Rotella T5 is 15W-40 anyways, so its right in the middle of thin vs thick.


This is exactly what I was thinking, I guess I named the thread wrong. NEW NAME: Which is less likely to cause ill effects during sludge removal- thin or thick?

Both thin or thick oil will both clean properly and really all oils will clean an engine if maintained properly, while Pennzoil may or may not be a better cleaner than others is a discussion for another time. If you are trying to clean an engine don't think that PP and PU are the only cleaning oils out there; QS, Castrol, VV, etc. all have cleaning properties.

I for example am trying to get rid of some sludge at the moment and will be changing the oil this weekend and will be going with QSUD and a quart of MMO. I was going to try PP but the QS is on clearance for $1.30 a quart so I'd be dumb not to buy it...wow this got way off topic...


Edited by RamFan (08/04/10 06:17 AM)
_________________________
06 Monte Carlo LT
+3.9l V6 - 142k - Havoline HM 5w30 - Security - OLM
14 CX-5 Grand Touring AWD
+2.5l I4 - 15k - Havoline 0w20 - Security - 6k/6mo

Top
#1975197 - 08/04/10 06:29 AM Re: Thin vs. Thick for sludge removal [Re: RamFan]
ronrackley Offline


Registered: 01/16/06
Posts: 175
Loc: Florida
I think the HDEOs having more dispersant - which they have to have to deal with the soot issue in diesel engines - recommends them for cleaning because it will help keep the dirt, crud (or whatever you want to call it) in suspension doing less harm until it can be drained out with the oil.

And, when I'm really serious about cleaning an engine I have some Marvel Mystery Oil in the crancase with the HDEO (usually Rotella 15 w 40) anyway. That thins it some.
_________________________
98 Volvo S90 - Rotella T6 5W40 - Wix
01 Toyota Tacoma - Rotella T6 5W40 - Wix
03 Deville - Rotella T6 5W40 - AC
05 Deville - Rotella T5 10W30 - AC

Top