Recent Topics
talent doesn't pay like it used to.
by motor_oil_madman
02/07/16 07:46 PM
Disappointed with Accord after one Salt Exposure
by JHZR2
02/07/16 06:58 PM
Valvoline white bottle 2.99 at Menard's.
by jhellwig
02/07/16 06:47 PM
EZ Car Lift Review
by JHZR2
02/07/16 06:32 PM
What oil for a beater vehicle?
by car51
02/07/16 06:01 PM
Buying services for new vehicles?
by powayroger
02/07/16 05:44 PM
Hard to find QSUD 0w20
by chiefsfan1
02/07/16 04:58 PM
Small compressor advice + a story of stupidity
by dishdude
02/07/16 04:33 PM
w116 300sd Lower shock bolt type/size
by Gito
02/07/16 04:20 PM
FRAM XG7317 Cut Open
by HX520W
02/07/16 04:17 PM
weld leaking on transmission pan.
by motor_oil_madman
02/07/16 03:41 PM
PP and Honda CR-V
by klt1986
02/07/16 03:04 PM
Newest Members
Compignite, pezman65, Wansu, DaleAZ, Nazmorgul
56846 Registered Users
Who's Online
101 registered (3800Series, 04SE, 901Memphis, 2002 Maxima SE, Abakev, AandPDan, 8 invisible), 1265 Guests and 220 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
56846 Members
66 Forums
244385 Topics
3979296 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#1861697 - 04/18/10 08:18 AM Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter?
ZZman Offline


Registered: 03/17/08
Posts: 4237
Loc: Michigan
Every car I have owned has had a spin on filter.

Is there any advantages to the cartridge filters other than possibly easier changing.

Are they bigger?
Have better flow?
Better Media/construction?
Easier to install a magnet in?
Etc....
_________________________
2002 Buick Regal GS (3.8 Supercharged) PP, Pure 1 filter
2008 Sebring Hardtop convertible (2.7) PP, Pure 1 filter.

Top
#1861704 - 04/18/10 08:27 AM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: ZZman]
tig1 Offline


Registered: 01/03/09
Posts: 10953
Loc: Illinois
Uses less materials. Steel, rubber,etc. Easier to inspect for contaminates. No differance in filtering quality.

A little differant to change, but not a real problem.
_________________________
2007 Ford Fusion 173,000 miles
M1 0-20 AFE
2007 Ford Focus 150,000 miles
M1 0-20 AFE
10,000 mile OCIs on both engines
M1 ATF
M1 10-30 in all OPE
MC filters


Top
#1861729 - 04/18/10 09:04 AM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: tig1]
Johnny248 Offline


Registered: 07/19/09
Posts: 2011
Loc: Detroit, MI
Less expensive to manufacture? Saves the manufacture cost when producing engines?
_________________________
'11 Ram 1500 5.7L
'08 Beetle 2.5L
'06 Eclipse GT 3.8L
'95 Four Winns Sundowner 5.0FI
'94 Honda Dio 72cc Big Bore


Top
#1861911 - 04/18/10 12:19 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: Johnny248]
SuperBusa Offline


Registered: 03/01/09
Posts: 2371
Loc: WA
Originally Posted By: Johnny248
Less expensive to manufacture?


Not sure about that. Seems cartridge filters are more expensive than spin-on filters. If they were less expensive to make, it seems like they would be much cheaper.
_________________________
Beta 1000
Condition 0

Top
#1861979 - 04/18/10 01:08 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: SuperBusa]
labman Offline


Registered: 03/14/03
Posts: 8711
Loc: Nothern USA
They look cheaper to make, but that hasn't filtered down to the consumer. The manufacturers may be ripping off the public,or somebody getting rich off a patent. They do use less steel. Nowhere to stick a magnet in mine. I think there are both well designed and poorly designed examples of each. The cartridge on my Ecotec is the easiest oil filter I ever changed. Leaving the ramps on the shelf is a huge factor.

Top
#1861990 - 04/18/10 01:16 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: ZZman]
mechanicx Offline


Registered: 10/23/09
Posts: 8576
Loc: Ohio
I don't see any performance advantage of a cartridge filter that is not installed before the oil pump pick up, and as far as I know all current new designs are upstream of the pump. As far as I can tell most cartridge filters are the equivalent of an ecore installed dome up without an ADBV.

Top
#1861995 - 04/18/10 01:21 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: labman]
mechanicx Offline


Registered: 10/23/09
Posts: 8576
Loc: Ohio
I think they are ripping off, because a common as dirt ecotec filter is scarcily different from a stripped down ecore, which tends to be cheaper anyway, and are made in 3rd world countries, yet run $8.88 at Walmart. The old 2.5 cartridge filter which was a classic stripped down and really not as common was usually priced slightly cheaper than a canister.

Top
#1862009 - 04/18/10 01:34 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: mechanicx]
LS2JSTS Offline


Registered: 09/05/09
Posts: 3844
Loc: Motor City..What's Left
The biggest advantage to me, is the ability to pull the filter and inspect it at any time, without having to drop the oil. Another is the ability to inspect the filter pleats after use without having to cut it open and create that mess.

Honestly most of the advantages fall to the manufacturers and the planet. Easier, cheaper and less complicated to manufacture. And less waste and resources spent on building and disposal.

For the record, all the cartridge filter/housing designs I've seen DO have an ADBV. But I have only seen a few, are there really cartridge designs out there with no ADBV built into the design. That would be weak.

Top
#1862019 - 04/18/10 01:45 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: LS2JSTS]
sayjac Offline


Registered: 10/13/08
Posts: 9263
Loc: The Old North State
I would agree with less use/waste of raw materials and disposal of said.

The fact that they charge more for less, you gotta love it.

Perhaps when they become more common the price will come down. In the meantime, don't hold your breath.

Top
#1862035 - 04/18/10 02:02 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: LS2JSTS]
mechanicx Offline


Registered: 10/23/09
Posts: 8576
Loc: Ohio
I agree that the cartridge filter has its advantages, but none of them are performance related. I sure can't tell where there is a rubber flap or valve on the cartridge filter that block off the filter feed hole shrug. I never really examined the cartridge filters oiling system. Maybe there's a ADBV separate from the filter. I personally think a dome down filter that can't drain back and is always full of oil, and the filter being as close to the pump as possible is the best but I don't have any proof.

Top
#1862085 - 04/18/10 02:49 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: mechanicx]
dishdude Offline


Registered: 11/14/08
Posts: 6056
Loc: Phoenix
When I had my Ecotecs, I loved how easy they were to change and how I was easily able to see the condition of the media. Also, I didn't have to worry about the construction of the can with fiber end caps, a silicone ADV valve or poorly constructed bypass valve.
_________________________
2015 Grand Cherokee 1k mi
2001 GMC Sonoma 207k mi

Top
#1862162 - 04/18/10 03:45 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: dishdude]
mechanicx Offline


Registered: 10/23/09
Posts: 8576
Loc: Ohio
I like the ecotec cartridge setup. It has its advantages. I just don't think it has any performance advantage over a canister and is somewhat overpriced. In the end it doesn't seem to effect engine wear or start up noise.

Top
#1862688 - 04/18/10 10:43 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: SuperBusa]
HTSS_TR Offline


Registered: 04/17/06
Posts: 17005
Loc: Lake Forest, CA
Originally Posted By: SuperBusa
Originally Posted By: Johnny248
Less expensive to manufacture?


Not sure about that. Seems cartridge filters are more expensive than spin-on filters. If they were less expensive to make, it seems like they would be much cheaper.


How can these cartridge filters are more expensive to make than spin-on filters ? But they cost more to consumers than a good spin-on filter such as P1. Mann, Mahle cartridge filters for '00 E430 are about $12-14 online and more than $20 at dealer.

These photos are copied from Quattro Pete's post, cartridge filter for '00 E430 is the same construction, the only difference is size.



_________________________
'94 Lexus LS400
'00 MB E430
'04 Honda S2000
'06 Volvo V70
"Throwing food away is like stealing it from the poor and hungry" Pope Francis

Top
#1865115 - 04/20/10 07:45 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: HTSS_TR]
PandaBear Offline


Registered: 08/05/02
Posts: 13028
Loc: Silicon Valley
to me it is more oil to be drain out of the filter and less into the landfill, and less metal to waste. Now you have the excuse that you can throw your used filter into the trash because they are already drained per the municipal required.
_________________________
"You keep asking questions PandaBear and you'll end up a vegetarian like my wife" - Camu Mahubah

Top
#1865335 - 04/20/10 11:11 PM Re: Advantage of Cartridge filter over Spin On Filter? [Re: HTSS_TR]
Quattro Pete Offline


Registered: 10/30/02
Posts: 30477
Loc: Great Lakes
Originally Posted By: HTSS_TR

These photos are copied from Quattro Pete's post, cartridge filter for '00 E430 is the same construction, the only difference is size.

These photos are of the filters for my 530i and they actually only cost about $5-$6 online, so less than a spin-on type M1 filter for example. So in fact yes, they are cheaper to make and cost less to the consumer. Of course some shops will put a huge markup on them, but that's another story.

If I'm not mistaken, the reason your E430 filters are more expensive is because they use fleece media as opposed to regular paper media like in my 530i. The paper version of your filter costs about $6-7 online.
_________________________
'02 530i (PPE 5W-40)
'15 Q5 3.0T (Edge 5W-40)

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >