Recent Topics
Airing up tires
by fordranger03
04/16/14 02:44 AM
Looking for a new DA Polisher
by The Critic
04/16/14 02:42 AM
Honda HRX 217
by cracker1970
04/15/14 11:45 PM
Just how crazy, exactly
by jrustles
04/15/14 11:37 PM
Leaking fuel at pressure regulator - gm 3.1 v6
by 901Memphis
04/15/14 11:18 PM
Maxlife ATF for VW?
by Johnny248
04/15/14 10:47 PM
What was Ford thinking?
by otis24
04/15/14 10:14 PM
what is friction modifer/limited slip additive?
by 1 FMF
04/15/14 10:01 PM
interesting video on composite fan blade building
by Rick in PA
04/15/14 09:54 PM
Docking Station for HP Envy 17 Laptop
by BigBird57
04/15/14 09:46 PM
Watch battery options
by Quattro Pete
04/15/14 09:45 PM
Is the 500 ml bottle of Iron X enough?
by gregk24
04/15/14 08:51 PM
Newest Members
Wiigy, MJR45, xlj, fresham, serf2k
49590 Registered Users
Who's Online
23 registered (01_celica_gt, David1, bourne, joaks, Garak, 3 invisible), 566 Guests and 204 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
49590 Members
64 Forums
211929 Topics
3321332 Posts

Max Online: 2551 @ 04/05/14 01:28 PM
Donate to BITOG

Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#1572697 - 08/20/09 09:54 AM Links to oil filter comparison tests?
lipadj46 Offline


Registered: 08/07/09
Posts: 1223
Loc: Western NY
Anyone have some links to direct comparison tests of oil filters?
_________________________
2002 Toyota Corolla, 65k miles, Mobil 1 0w30
2004 WV Passat Wagon 94k Miles, Rotella T6
2002 Land Rover Discovery Totaled RIP

Top
#1572701 - 08/20/09 09:56 AM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: lipadj46]
labman Offline


Registered: 03/14/03
Posts: 8711
Loc: Nothern USA
You want facts to base your decisions on?

Top
#1572703 - 08/20/09 10:00 AM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: lipadj46]
Saturn_Fan Offline


Registered: 01/06/08
Posts: 2512
Loc: America's Dairyland
Originally Posted By: lipadj46
Anyone have some links to direct comparison tests of oil filters?


Ask and you shall receive. This has been updated in 2008. This study was 9 years before the update and I remember when it first came out.

Enjoy!

http://minimopar.knizefamily.net/oilfilters/index.html


Here is a direct link to what the study recommends for oil filters: http://minimopar.knizefamily.net/oilfilters/opinions.html


Edited by Saturn_Fan (08/20/09 10:02 AM)
_________________________
08 Toyota Corolla CE, 20K miles, 1ZZ-FE 1.8L, Castrol Edge 5w-30 & M1 EP filter
00 Saturn SL, 108K miles, 1.9L, Pennz Plat 5w-30 & M1 EP filter

Top
#1572720 - 08/20/09 10:12 AM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: Saturn_Fan]
lipadj46 Offline


Registered: 08/07/09
Posts: 1223
Loc: Western NY
Thanks!
_________________________
2002 Toyota Corolla, 65k miles, Mobil 1 0w30
2004 WV Passat Wagon 94k Miles, Rotella T6
2002 Land Rover Discovery Totaled RIP

Top
#1572724 - 08/20/09 10:16 AM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: lipadj46]
tomcat27 Offline


Registered: 06/25/09
Posts: 2394
Loc: Midwest

Top
#1572743 - 08/20/09 10:31 AM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: tomcat27]
ZZman Offline


Registered: 03/17/08
Posts: 4228
Loc: Michigan
What I would like to see is true filtering tests for filters. % they filter and amount they hold before they go into bypass mode.
_________________________
2002 Buick Regal GS (3.8 Supercharged) PP, Pure 1 filter
2008 Sebring Hardtop convertible (2.7) M1, Pure 1 filter.

Top
#1572750 - 08/20/09 10:37 AM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: ZZman]
Saturn_Fan Offline


Registered: 01/06/08
Posts: 2512
Loc: America's Dairyland
Originally Posted By: ZZman
What I would like to see is true filtering tests for filters. % they filter and amount they hold before they go into bypass mode.


+1. These comparisons are mostly all beautiful photography with a good dose of conjecture. Better testing is needed for sure.
_________________________
08 Toyota Corolla CE, 20K miles, 1ZZ-FE 1.8L, Castrol Edge 5w-30 & M1 EP filter
00 Saturn SL, 108K miles, 1.9L, Pennz Plat 5w-30 & M1 EP filter

Top
#1572945 - 08/20/09 01:41 PM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: Saturn_Fan]
labman Offline


Registered: 03/14/03
Posts: 8711
Loc: Nothern USA
+1

This really reminds me of the endless discussions of dog food in the dog forums. Most people on the net believe www.dogfoodanalysis.com is the gospel. They have dug up the ingredients in all the different ones, assigned values to each one, and rate all the foods. What is missing is any studies relating the values they assign to the ingredients to the health of the dogs eating foods with those ingredients.

Long before the internet became an unparalleled source of misinformation, Labman's family was raising puppies for a dog guide school. They breed hundreds of puppies a year, provide all the medical care for most of them the first year. At the end of it, they do a complete physical including hip X-rays on all of them. They then spent $35,000 training them before giving them away. They have a large data base of breeding records. Dogs with any physical or temperamental problems are unfit for the program and are a waste. Their well equipped clinic and vet staff are available for serious problems as long as the dog is working. When the dog is no longer able to work, it is replaced at again the $35,000 plus a large emotional upheaval for the person depending on the dog. You think they don't know what foods work, and select a good one?

According to dogfoodanalysis, the Pro Plan they feed is junk along with the Iams and Science Diet other service dog schools use.

So at www.oilfilteranalysis.com, we cut open filters, stretch out the media. measure it, note other details of construction including the all important end caps, etc. and rate the filters. Of course, we have little idea of how good the media is in any of them, how much we really need, does crud wash into the bearings through dome end bypasses, etc. Note, the details of filter construction keep changing, just like ingredients in dog food.

What do we expect of an oil filter? Reducing wear with very low risk of leaking. What problems I had in maybe a half million miles? The EMPI filters I used on my truck in 1977 didn't have a groove to retain the gasket and it blew out. The second time was almost in front of Mr. Goodwrench. I walked back and gave them the keys and explained the problem. When I returned, I was told it had an AC filter like it should and to keep it that way. They ran $5 back then.

What real study of filters do we have? The old CR and NYC taxicabs study where Frams did so well?

Top
#1572978 - 08/20/09 02:06 PM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: labman]
ZZman Offline


Registered: 03/17/08
Posts: 4228
Loc: Michigan
I sent a request into CR to do an in depth filter test. I guess the interest was not there.


Edited by ZZman (08/20/09 02:06 PM)
_________________________
2002 Buick Regal GS (3.8 Supercharged) PP, Pure 1 filter
2008 Sebring Hardtop convertible (2.7) M1, Pure 1 filter.

Top
#1573009 - 08/20/09 02:39 PM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: ZZman]
daman Offline


Registered: 09/23/06
Posts: 10415
Loc: Bad Axe, MI
He shouldnt say the M1 and K&N are exactly the same there not,M1's filter media is as different,filters better then the K&N.

and he saw the same problem i see with them c rapy ST;

"cheaply made and the felt end caps detached from the filter media with frightening ease"





_________________________
"Always"....Mobil 1

Current fill: AFE 0w30

Top
#1573213 - 08/20/09 06:21 PM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: labman]
[RT] ProjUltraZ Offline


Registered: 12/16/04
Posts: 1046
Loc: Honolulu, HI
Originally Posted By: labman
So at www.oilfilteranalysis.com, we cut open filters, stretch out


link is 404

Top
#1573221 - 08/20/09 06:34 PM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: [RT] ProjUltraZ]
chevrofreak Offline


Registered: 06/17/05
Posts: 4893
Loc: Billings, MT
Originally Posted By: [RT
ProjUltraZ]
Originally Posted By: labman
So at www.oilfilteranalysis.com, we cut open filters, stretch out


link is 404


Fail.
_________________________
I <3 Red Line oil

Top
#1692204 - 12/02/09 09:19 AM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: chevrofreak]
ELW Offline


Registered: 11/29/09
Posts: 14
Loc: Maryland, US
This is one of the best filter studies I've found:

http://home.mindspring.com/~cewhite3nc/index.html

_________________________
94 Toyota Land Cruiser
205K mi
6K OCI
PureOne PL30001
considering:
-Chevron Delo 400 Multigrade 15W-40 (235101, not LE)
-Chevron Supreme High Mileage 10W-40

Top
#1693168 - 12/02/09 09:38 PM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: ELW]
labman Offline


Registered: 03/14/03
Posts: 8711
Loc: Nothern USA
Not a bad study in its day. What at least fourth link to it in the last month?

Top
#1693306 - 12/02/09 11:50 PM Re: Links to oil filter comparison tests? [Re: daman]
SuperBusa Offline


Registered: 03/01/09
Posts: 2371
Loc: WA
Originally Posted By: daman

.... and he saw the same problem i see with them c rapy ST;

"cheaply made and the felt end caps detached from the filter media with frightening ease"



Actually the "felt" end caps are not glued, but "thermally bonded". In any case, the seal is definitely not good in the areas pointed out in the photo.

Hey, just consider it a "built in bypass filter". wink
_________________________
Beta 1000
Condition 0

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >