G-009s have a higher load rating than BFGs. Not a big deal, probally a better built tire though.
ASX are $46, nice
General Altimax are worth a shot, they are new. I use the General Exclaims now, pretty awesome. Made in France by Conti.
TRZ are $63 and would be my pick from eperience and the fact that is not a lot of $ for a great tire.
H4S are $65, more performance, wear is still good at 500 but not good in snow.
The size change is a DEFINATE. You can't go wrong with any of these, almost all are reviewed right here on this forum.