The way I see things, the Redline is better for cleaning up deposits and stuff, where the FP is a better UCL with some cleaning abilities over time. I would hesitate to use the Redline on a continuous basis unless if was a very small dose. And yes, both work very well. If I had both of these products on the shelf of my shop, i would use the Redline at full strenth dose to clean up injectors, valves, etc, just before an oil change. Then I would use the FP Plus at every fill-up to keep things clean, as well as top end lubed and as a fuel economy improver. Where are you seeing the Redline SI-1? The only place I see it now is Pep Boys and they are about 40 miles from me.