As I mentioned before, M1 15-50 will work just fine on the XR650. I have plenty of time on that bike, I installed a HRC power up kit. That included the piston, cam, head work, carb work, airbox work and a homemade straight through exhaust and header. Believe me, I know that bike fairly well.
Those bikes tend to overheat down here in Florida. Especially with the corked up stock exhaust and carb. Installing the HRC power up kit really brings the engine to life. The RWHP goes up about 10HP. Even with all that extra power the stock clutch will not slip with M1 15-50.
And, that bike is hard on oil, mostly due to the temperatures it runs. It will boil over here in Florida even with a 1.6bar cap.
I am sorry for not being as clear in my first post. I guess I left it open for debate.
Chris