This is what dnewton advised me about the G80 in my '02 Suburban (
http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubb...han#Post3140059)
Originally Posted By: dnewton
Rear diff:
GM's fluid spec (9986115) is merely a designation of a syn 75w-90 with LS additive, and nothing more. There is a quote from a guy named Michael Torrenson (or something similar to that) who worked for Eaton, where he indicates that ANY GL-5 fluid will be OK for a GM G-80 diff, and the only concern is to make sure you use one with a LS additive, because the G-80 "locker" actually has a clutch engagement system. Just about any decent GL-5 lube will work here, but syn's are going to give you a longer OCI, so they might be worth the investment. Most of the syns, and some of the dinos, will have LS additive already included. Of note, the 80w-90 Valvoline does I know for sure, because I just put some in my Ford diff this weekend. If you live in super-hot areas, AND you town for the MAJORITY of the operational time, then I'd "upgrade" to a 85w-140. But ONLY if you meet BOTH of those criteria. If you don't, then use a 75w-90 syn or 80w-90 dino that meets SAE J2360. Adjust your OCI to your fluid type. If you have a G-80 locking diff (and most did) then you must use a LS compliant fluid. You will need to either buy a fluid with LS additive included, or put it in separately. Regardless of what others state, the G-80 does have clutches. They often mistakenly think that the "locker" is a mechanical type, but it is actually a pawl-operated clutch system. It has clutches. You need LS additive if you have a G-80.
So I'd go with an LS fluid or add an LS additive. Of the two choices you listed, I'd go with the Valvoline, which is on the J2360 list dnewton referenced, whereas Mobil 1 is not (but Delvac is!).