Best oil drain pan?

Status
Not open for further replies.
paulri

paulri

Joined
Aug 14, 2015
Messages
2,442
Location
CA, USA
I'm getting rid of the one I have now--it is too floppy and the fluid runs out too much when I try to pour it into the jug. So hard plastic is one requirement.

Are there any drain pans that you would recommend--or recommend that I stay away from? I'll be using this for draining oil and coolant, although my next coolant drain is 3 years away.

I'd like to stay under 20 bucks if in any way possible.
 
I've been using a small bucket from the dollar store for years. Fits underneath all my cars and the added height allows the entering fluid to just go straight in and not splash around everywhere.
 
Under $20 quick solution: a shallow Rubbermaid container.

Under $20 long game: scope out garage sales and craigslist for an old-school metal drain pan.
 
I use one of these http://shop.advanceautoparts.com/p/flotool-5-gallon-drain-pan-11845mi/89011620-P?navigationPath=L1*14924%7CL2*15045%7CL3*16237 i think I got it from WMT. A sawed off 5 gallon joint compound bucket works too.
 
https://www.walmart.com/ip/RhinoGear-15-Qt-Oil-Drain-Pan/20440558

I like the funnelly things where the oil gets trapped "inside" then pours out the snout.

This one has a slight design flaw, the top portion is a little shallow for my taste. Might splatter slightly.

But not having to use a separate funnel with all its ickiness is a real bonus.

I would use a dollar tree dishpan for your antifreeze work, BTW.
 
I've bought a couple at the dollar tree. They are [censored] but they last long enough to do my annual maintenance on the cars so for $1 per year it works for me. I live in an apartment in the city and have nowhere to store an oily pan.
 
Originally Posted By: JC1
Originally Posted By: xshoex
I have a 15qt from wallyworld $10

https://www.walmart.com/ip/44580714?wmls...13=&veh=sem

I love it


+1, get this you won't be disappointed.

+2

I also have this drain pan. Not perfect but good bang for the buck. Nice touch that it has two drain holes. If you have ever had the "pleasure" of the drain bolt dropping into the drain hole on the typical drain pan, you will appreciate the peace of mind of this feature.
 
Haven't used a drain pan for oil in years. Buy a Fumoto nipple type, attach a hose, and drain directly to a jug. Saves a lot of mess, pouring, cleaning up, etc.
 
I got tired of dropping drain plugs and got this OTC 5911 tool
219Ha7pTs3L._SX355_.jpg


The magnet is very strong and I haven't dropped a drain plug since I bought the tool.
 
Originally Posted By: George7941
I got tired of dropping drain plugs and got this OTC 5911 tool
219Ha7pTs3L._SX355_.jpg


The magnet is very strong and I haven't dropped a drain plug since I bought the tool.


I was looking at that tool today at o'reillys.
 
Originally Posted By: eljefino
https://www.walmart.com/ip/RhinoGear-15-Qt-Oil-Drain-Pan/20440558

I like the funnelly things where the oil gets trapped "inside" then pours out the snout.

This one has a slight design flaw, the top portion is a little shallow for my taste. Might splatter slightly.

But not having to use a separate funnel with all its ickiness is a real bonus.

I would use a dollar tree dishpan for your antifreeze work, BTW.


I just broke mine; I liked it. Only one real issue: don't fill it to the max. I drained both vehicles into it, 13qt, and it just was too unwieldy.

Died as the cap on the drain end gave up.
frown.gif


I did buy this as a replacement:
Originally Posted By: bubbatime
These style pans are a FREAKING MESS and I cant freaking stand them:
https://www.walmart.com/ip/44580714?wmls...13=&veh=sem

so I'm sad to hear the poor review. Haven't used yet, so I guess I can return (have about 4 months before needing it).

I don't care for open pans. I usually drop the drain into the pan, and likewise drop filter&cannister onto the pan for draining. I'd rather not fish around in the pan afterwards.
 
I used to have a tall, odd 6 qt. can which hugged the drain hole so NOTHING could splatter. I used it 'til it sprung a leak. The metal actually pinholed.

Replaced with the black, spouted type people are posting here. It is the best.

The "Lay-on-thier-sides" jerry can style mentioned here is ridiculous. Even if you merely cracked the drain plug and let the oil dribble for an hour it'd still splatter all over the place. Then, when you stood it up, the outside of the jug would drip all over the place.

I've found that "metal ones" are all too big for home driveway use. They are for farm equipment and can hold 20+ qt.
 
Never had a problem with splatter, although I have a dirt driveway. I'd hate to have jack up a foot in order to use a tall catchpan.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

C
Free to Good Home - 7 or 8 Drainplugs for Plastic Silverado Oil Pan
Replies
0
Views
313
CapitalTruck
mrsilv04
It never fails.... oil pan drain plug threads stripped out by mechanic.
3 4 5
Replies
89
Views
9K
billt460
G
Oil pan bolt threads are weak, going to install a Fumoto valve. How to make sure it stays?
2
Replies
30
Views
3K
srfdude
Deadwood
2021 Toyota Tundra : First DIY oil change, lessons learned
Replies
10
Views
3K
Deadwood
B
Did I destroy my engine?
Replies
17
Views
4K
bluesriderdf
Back
Top