Originally Posted By: Silverado12
I don't know if I would replace a rear main seal if it's not already leaking. I have seen seals actually cut into the crankshaft a little before they wear out.
Even if the elastomer is sealing properly, over time the elastomer hardens from the heat and that may cause it to dig into the shaft at an accelerated rate. I recently replaced the camshaft and crankshaft seals on my 4Runner and the crankshaft seal had noticeable discoloration due to the hotter temperatures down there. All the seals were still functioning fine, but you could tell the 20 yr old seal was much harder than the fresh new ones.
That's why when it comes to seals, I don't believe in the "if aint broke, don't fix it" approach. If it's easy to do while you have everything apart, do it.