Originally Posted By: Shrubitup
Originally Posted By: Cujet
As a young man, I worked for a outboard race engine development team. One thing we tested was the affect of oil ratio on engine output. More oil makes more HP, all the way to 8 to 1. We also determined that 32 to 1 was the ratio that provided the highest wear protection, more oil did not help. BUT, Leaner ratio's resulted in more wear, with 100 to 1 showing significant piston skirt and ring wear.
Not insulting your age or wisdom but likely the best oil used back then did in fact cause accelerated wear at 100:1. Today's oil at this ratio in a low performance application likely don't wear as bad as what you saw.
That's just the thing I'm trying to get people to understand. Two stroke oils are not significantly better at lubricating today! They are, however, significantly better at preventing deposits. (which does result in longer engine life, no more stuck rings and plugged exhaust ports)
Also, in engines with such a lean oil ratio, say 100 to 1, quite simply, the engine is at the threshold of inadequate lubrication under all conditions, regardless of oil type. Even the most pedestrian of two stroke engines produce excellent power and are highly loaded.
In fact, in recent test after test, the exact same results show up. I posted some results above. The magic super synthetic oils, run at lean ratio's result in accelerated wear, period. Regardless of what the oil claims.
Outboard engines do often operate at lean ratio's. They are water cooled, and designed to operate with minimal oil. Even so, at higher RPM and load, they do increase oil flow considerably. Hence the variable ratio oiling systems.
Your chainsaw, trimmer, lawnboy mower and other 2 cycle yard equipment are air cooled, high RPM, reasonably high performance engines. And in fact, often make considerably more HP per displacement than outboards.
Note: Variable ratio averages about 60:1, slightly leaner at idle and slightly richer at full throttle. The older pumps idled between 150:1 (prior to 1990) and engine failures were the result The pumps were changed to idle at 100:1 (1990-1992), then richened up to 50:1 as the engine load increased. Even so, many owners pulled the VRO pumps off due to rapid engine wear.