Originally Posted By: 02s4audi
So what about amsoil DEO 5w40? It's a little thicker than most. Also has a high additive pack compared to most. Would it be any different compared to running rotella t6? Tons of people are running rotella in my engine.
Originally Posted By: BrianC
DEO is a diesel oil designed for heavy duty diesel applications as is Rotella T6.
Both can have phosphorus levels as high as 1200 ppm. Not good for catalytic converters. Again, the best oil for your application is one that meets VW 502.
Amsoil DEO is a fine choice for an OUT OF WARRANTY German gasoline engine (since it does NOT meet the requisite specifications).
DEO 5W40 IS API SN rated, and is fine for gasoline engines. 1200 ppm of phosphorus is not an issue, as Mobil 1 0W40 has 1000 ppm and it is used around the world in gas engines. The 200 ppm will not make any difference in a healthy engine. DEO is a robust oil and will most likely offer great protection.
If the car is drinking oil by the gallon, then you'll likely have a converter problem no matter what oil is being used.