Originally Posted By: A_Harman
Originally Posted By: supton
Looks like the 200 and 229 were odd fire, while the 4.3 was always even. Wikipedia Link
I forget, do 60 degree V6's need balance shafts?
*
This new V6 is quite a step ahead, but it seems still a step behind. 285hp? Seems like everyone else is running 300+hp, and in the end, hp gets the work done.
Now if it had a proper transmission you could lug the motor a bit and let its torque run free...
The 200 and 229 V6's were odd fire, but they did have split crankpins. On those engines, the pins were split 18 degrees instead of the 30 degrees required to make a 90 degree V6 even-firing.
Yes, 60 degree V6's need balance shafts to eliminate free moments caused by piston accelerations. Any V-type engine with an odd number of cylinders on a bank will have free moments.
The new 4.3 V6 basically replaces the 4.8L V8. Comparing the power and torque figures:
4.3 V6 makes 285 HP @ 5300 rpm, and 305 ft*lbs @ 3900 rpm
4.8 V8 makes 285 HP @ 5400 rpm, and 295 ft*lbs @ 4300 rpm
And comparing to the 3.6 V6:
288 HP @ 6300 rpm, 270 ft*lbs @ 3400 rpm in the Traverse, which is the heaviest vehicle that GM puts the 3.6 in. Yes, it makes more power in cars and small SUV's. But 278 ft*lbs of torque is as much as it makes in any vehicle, and that's at 4800 rpm in the Camaro.
Not only that, but if you compare the power curves of the new 4.3L to even the most powerful 3.6L, the 3.6L is only making more HP at over 5,000 5,500 rpm, I don't remember exactly. The 4.3L is far more powerful in the rpm's I'd normally be using. Seems like a pretty nice motor.
Originally Posted By: supton
Looks like the 200 and 229 were odd fire, while the 4.3 was always even. Wikipedia Link
I forget, do 60 degree V6's need balance shafts?
*
This new V6 is quite a step ahead, but it seems still a step behind. 285hp? Seems like everyone else is running 300+hp, and in the end, hp gets the work done.
Now if it had a proper transmission you could lug the motor a bit and let its torque run free...
The 200 and 229 V6's were odd fire, but they did have split crankpins. On those engines, the pins were split 18 degrees instead of the 30 degrees required to make a 90 degree V6 even-firing.
Yes, 60 degree V6's need balance shafts to eliminate free moments caused by piston accelerations. Any V-type engine with an odd number of cylinders on a bank will have free moments.
The new 4.3 V6 basically replaces the 4.8L V8. Comparing the power and torque figures:
4.3 V6 makes 285 HP @ 5300 rpm, and 305 ft*lbs @ 3900 rpm
4.8 V8 makes 285 HP @ 5400 rpm, and 295 ft*lbs @ 4300 rpm
And comparing to the 3.6 V6:
288 HP @ 6300 rpm, 270 ft*lbs @ 3400 rpm in the Traverse, which is the heaviest vehicle that GM puts the 3.6 in. Yes, it makes more power in cars and small SUV's. But 278 ft*lbs of torque is as much as it makes in any vehicle, and that's at 4800 rpm in the Camaro.
Not only that, but if you compare the power curves of the new 4.3L to even the most powerful 3.6L, the 3.6L is only making more HP at over 5,000 5,500 rpm, I don't remember exactly. The 4.3L is far more powerful in the rpm's I'd normally be using. Seems like a pretty nice motor.