Hardest filter to Change????

Status
Not open for further replies.
My 2004.5 Dodge Ram 2500 4x4 with Cummins is kind of tough for me-The filterhead is clear up and the LF corner of the engine, down and below the air cleaner box and tubing. To get at it from the top you must take the intake tract all apart, and to get it from the bottom you need a 4' long arm that's skinny so you can snake it up between the starter motor, wiring, etc and still manage to grip the filter. I have somewhat long arms and I still have to sit up with my head and neck pressed against the bottom side of the truck to reach it. I don't have skinny arms so that really cramps me down on room. And you have to be lying the right direction so that the crook in your arm can bend the proper way to get on it.

Getting a wrench in there is next to impossible as well--I had to get one of the orange deals that goes on the bottom of the filter and you can stick a socket or breaker bar, etc. into the bottom to crank it off. When I have to use it, I have to find every socket extension on the farm to get it long enough to reach way up in there, and then the orange piece invariably slips because I can't keep it suare with the bottom of the filter with all the extensions. The best part then it that the filter is full of oil and there is no way to snake your arm back out and keep it completely upright, so then the oil comes cascading back down your arm and all over you, so I slip something over the filter now to keep that from happening.


I use Mobil 1 filters now primarily because they seem to come off pretty easily on this truck.

My mom's Jeep Liberty 3.7 is no picnic either--I have a heck of a time getting the filter snug enough for my taste while hanging over the front of the engine compartment because I just can't get a good angle on the thing.

04 Chevy 2500 x4 w/ 6.0L gasser, and our TDI Jetta are the easiest, although I hate how the oil runs forever out of the filter mount on the Chevy.
 
I've probably got 2 of the worst.
Jeep Liberty 3.7L V-6. Filter is hidden behind the skid plate. No way to get a normal filter wrench on it.
Ford Escort 2.0L Hidden behind the engine, very tight area.
 
Jeez, I did all the oil changes on my friends '97 Sunbird (4 speed auto if that made a difference) and didn't find it bad. That car was super reliable by the way. In general most 4 bangers that a have filter mounted on the back of the block, next to the firewall are a PIA, e.g. my '99 Escort ZX2 (2.0 Zetec).
 
Let's see, the GM 2.5 iron duke wasn't so bad, as long as you had a wide enough catch pan and the numbskull at the quickie lube place didn't torque the drain plug on. I take that back, it was bad if the pliers let go and dropped the cartridge into the pan of oil, splashing it all over you. That's not so good.

My '97 Saturn SL2 didn't get high marks, it usually made a mess all over the CV boot. Also required putting it on ramps to reach it.

My dad's '86 Buick Lesabre wasn't terrific either. I recall it was hard to get the wrench around it, and I had to turn the front wheels to reach it.

My '04 Honda CR-V is pretty lousy. Makes a big mess all over the frame.

Girlfriend's '05 Subaru Legacy wagon is a dream come true. Out in the open, easy to get to, nothing to get oil all over, and I actually like changing the oil on that.

My dad's '47 Lincoln V-12 had the right idea though. A separate housing under the hood you take the top off of, pull out the old cartridge, and slip a new cartridge in. No mess, no fuss, no spilled oil.
 
Any Toyota/Lexus with the stupid canister that's almost always on so tight you have to sacrifice a filter cup socket just to get it loose.
That's what I thought after my first oil change on our 2012 Corolla, the dealer had it on super tight. 9 years later it's easy since I've done it everytime since.
 
1624723287459.jpeg
 
In all fairness, the site does seem to trick people into doing this. I've been in some threads and saw interesting things in the 'Similar Threads' portion that I was going to respond to, then caught myself when I noticed that the similar thread is from years back.
 
Worst one I've changed oil in is a current 1.0L 3yl Ecoboost. Filter is up high on backside of engine. It's over the axle shaft. No way to drain it without getting on everything or creating a makeshift funnel or dam to catch the oil and divert it.
It's in an Ecosport vehicle. That 1.0L is tiny. AFAIK worldwide it's only used in the Fiesta, Ecosport, and Focus. There is actually plenty of room under the hood and around the engine. Could have easily engineed the oil filter to an easier location.
 
2006-2011 Honda Civic Si with the K20z3, if the car is hot forget it you burn the crap outta your arm trying to reach the filter. i would have to wear those kevlar heat sleeves and when you do get it off my god it makes a friggen mess. all over the axle and boot, the subframe just horrendous.
 
Any car with the GM 2.5L 4 cyl. "Iron Duke". Impossible to remove the internal filter without spraying oil everywhere.
rolleyes.gif


otherwise a good engine....
Didn't think it was all that bad on my 1985 S-10 little pickup truck. Not bad at all.
 
You sure it was not a H3 ? We had a new 2009 H3 with the 5 cylinder. The H2 was a MUCH bigger vehicle.
We had the same year H3 … wife ended up hating the blind spots (near misses) so only kept it a couple years …
 
Son could not get the filter off the Fusion (up against cross member) … fortunately an XG
Just bought an FL400S for the length … will change that and do another 5k on the oil (10k)
If the 400 fits good … plan to get an XG3600 for next time …
 
If a topic interests you please start a new topic. Responding to a 17 year old topic wastes everyone's time
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top