Originally Posted By: 97tbird
Terribly cheaply made interior (that's how they dropped the price on that generation) is WELL documented. Might wanna read up on that a bit ...
You're confused on years.
The 2010 is the last year of the MK5, so it still has the high-quality interior and independent rear suspension. 2011 is when they started the dumbed-down, de-contented MK6. The interiors on the MK6 really are bad.
I looked at a 2011. I don't really care that much about the hard plastic dash, as I never touch the dash. But the door panels and every other interior panel is also cheap, hard plastic. It's a huge step down from my 2010 Jetta.
To the OP-
I have a 2010 Jetta. The driving dynamics and interior quality are way better than most cars in the class. It's sort of a semi-premium small car.
Mine has the manual and it has a nice shifter and clutch compared to other cars in the class.
By 2010, it seems VW had improved their reliability over the 1990s and early 2000s cars that gave them a bad name, but it's not perfect. The door latch mechanisms fail pretty commonly. I have already replaced one and another one is now failing.
It's now 4 years old and has 50k miles. Other than the door latch, it's been problem free. Maintenance isn't anything crazy. 10k oil changes with full syn that meets vw 502 and other normal flushes. The 2.5 has a timing chain, not a belt.
By the time our 2000 New Beetle was 4 years old it was getting quite a few electrical problems, so the Jetta is definitely better in that regard.
Mine has the 2.5. Don't believe the hate spread by auto journalists. The 2.5 is a solid engine and is reliable. The early years had timing chain issues, but that was fixed well before 2010.
The 2.5 may not be the most refined, powerful or fuel efficient engine, but it's not the worst engine in those areas, either. It's harsh sounding before it warms up, but then it's perfectly smooth and quiet. It has a nice growl when you get on it, too.
One thing the car needs is a 6th gear on the manual trans. The RPM are too high on the highway when I'm cruising at 75. A 6th gear would improve mileage.