Recent Topics
CHEVRON DELO Reveals their line up of CK-4/FA-4
by Powerstroke
08/27/16 03:07 PM
New belt or new belt tensioner?
by Parlay_Slow
08/27/16 02:53 PM
PP 5w-30 Amazon subscribe and save
by buck91
08/27/16 01:52 PM
My parents took my nissan s13 silvia
by Nissan101
08/27/16 01:21 PM
New Hyundia Santa Cruz pickup with extendable bed
by gfh77665
08/27/16 01:12 PM
Pro Line PPL 14610 4,000 miles CUT OPEN
by car51
08/27/16 01:00 PM
STP S-10590 6,000 miles CUT OPEN
by car51
08/27/16 12:47 PM
Store Kerosense in Non-Vented Container?
by ET16
08/27/16 12:16 PM
Opinion on Salvage Title
by DBMaster
08/27/16 12:14 PM
Different labels for 303 protectant
by 007
08/27/16 12:07 PM
cstoremotoroil.com
by AirgunSavant
08/27/16 09:37 AM
What's good/bad about a 2006 Mazda 5?
by 55Test
08/27/16 09:30 AM
Newest Members
therhett17, glldprimr, krankshaft, Tony_Rhed, greasemonkey1
58935 Registered Users
Who's Online
69 registered (albertdi, 2009Edge, amusing, AandPDan, alanwayne1908, 4WD, 6 invisible), 1740 Guests and 37 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
58935 Members
66 Forums
253630 Topics
4163649 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#3466170 - 08/27/14 10:11 AM PU better than PP in 5w30?
lukejo Offline


Registered: 09/21/11
Posts: 243
Loc: IL
I know this has been discussed a lot, but now that PU is published with a higher Noack than PP (in 5w30), and all other published numbers look nearly identical, is there any obvious reason to go with PU other than the advertised claims of better cleaning?

((I understand both are great oils and will far surpass my requirements...am just trying to learn what I might be missing that others are seeing.))

Top
#3466174 - 08/27/14 10:13 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
HangFire Offline


Registered: 08/21/13
Posts: 1779
Loc: Central Maryland
I've been scratching my head about this as well. Also IIRC Pennzoil yellow bottle 5w-20 has a lower Noack than their 5w-30. Go figure.
_________________________
Various musings: http://hangfire.net

Top
#3466179 - 08/27/14 10:18 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
timeau Offline


Registered: 10/07/05
Posts: 297
Loc: Maryland
Originally Posted By: lukejo
I know this has been discussed a lot, but now that PU is published with a higher Noack than PP (in 5w30), and all other published numbers look nearly identical, is there any obvious reason to go with PU other than the advertised claims of better cleaning?

PU has higher amount of calcium (2700 vs 2300 ppm), which is a cleaning additive. So this definitely should clean better and run longer. Compare to Amsoil, where 3300+ ppm of calcium.
To be more exact, need to look on Ca+Mg combination.
_________________________
-----
2013 Toyota Camry XLE V6
2012 Honda Accord EX-L V6

Top
#3466182 - 08/27/14 10:21 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: timeau]
lukejo Offline


Registered: 09/21/11
Posts: 243
Loc: IL
Okay, that's good to know. Where do you find those levels? I have just been looking at their Technical Data Sheet on their site.

Top
#3466194 - 08/27/14 10:30 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
OneEyeJack Offline


Registered: 09/14/10
Posts: 5420
Loc: S California
VOA?

Top
#3466233 - 08/27/14 11:04 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
timeau Offline


Registered: 10/07/05
Posts: 297
Loc: Maryland
Originally Posted By: lukejo
Where do you find those levels?

I think VOA section on this site is a best place to look.
_________________________
-----
2013 Toyota Camry XLE V6
2012 Honda Accord EX-L V6

Top
#3466260 - 08/27/14 11:28 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
Apollo14 Offline


Registered: 08/18/14
Posts: 884
Loc: CA
Head over to the PQIA website for comparisons.

If the cost difference is negligible or I had more cleaning needs, I would go with PU.

Top
#3466265 - 08/27/14 11:30 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
ARCOgraphite Offline


Registered: 05/17/09
Posts: 10099
Loc: N.H, U.S.A.
Base stock makeup is more important than small Ca level differences. The higher overbase will show more long drain capability but possibly MORE wear in a low saps oil if not balanced with other premium AW/EP agents/lubricants.
_________________________
2014 Nissan Rogue S CVT, OC#4 19671mi-Castrol EDGE EP 5W30+Nissan 15208-9E01A Filter
2015 Forester 6MT 5Door, OC#6 41243mi-M1EP 0W20+Subaru Filter

Top
#3466269 - 08/27/14 11:33 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
Nate1979 Offline


Registered: 04/08/13
Posts: 3296
Loc: Portland, OR
Better? What does that even mean? Noack is just one parameter of many.
_________________________
2015 GMC Sierra 2500 6.0L Factory fill
2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X QSUD 5w-30 w/ Fram Ultra

Top
#3466273 - 08/27/14 11:38 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: Nate1979]
lukejo Offline


Registered: 09/21/11
Posts: 243
Loc: IL
Originally Posted By: Nate1979
Better? What does that even mean? Noack is just one parameter of many.

Exactly, that was my question. As I said, I was only viewing the Tech Data on their site and Noack is the only parameter I see that is different. Obviously "better" means something, or there is no reason for a price difference. You tell me.

Top
#3466274 - 08/27/14 11:39 AM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: Apollo14]
lukejo Offline


Registered: 09/21/11
Posts: 243
Loc: IL
Originally Posted By: Apollo14
Head over to the PQIA website for comparisons.

If the cost difference is negligible or I had more cleaning needs, I would go with PU.

Thanks, will do.

Top
#3466304 - 08/27/14 12:15 PM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
Apollo14 Offline


Registered: 08/18/14
Posts: 884
Loc: CA

Top
#3466306 - 08/27/14 12:22 PM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: Apollo14]
Rand Online   content


Registered: 08/20/03
Posts: 10560
Loc: NE,Ohio


Thats not the current formulation of PU or PP.
so not very applicable.
_________________________
2015 Forester I-Premium 6MT

Top
#3466328 - 08/27/14 12:53 PM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
GM4LIFE Offline


Registered: 08/18/14
Posts: 351
Loc: Texas
I am curious as to the real difference between Pennzoil Platinum and the Ultra Platinum.

Is the Platinum comparable to regular Mobil 1?

Is the Ultra Platinum comparable to Mobil 1 EP?

Top
#3466334 - 08/27/14 12:58 PM Re: PU better than PP in 5w30? [Re: lukejo]
SilverC6 Offline


Registered: 10/03/08
Posts: 2785
Loc: Southeast
http://www.pqiamerica.com/March2013PCMO/Marchsyntheticsallfinal.html

When I see that chart, I always gravitate toward how mediocre Royal Purple 5W-30 "boutique" oil is compared to the majors and its uncanny similarity to Valvoline Synpower and NAPA's house branded Valvoline synthetic.

It's like RP just buys a truck load of Valvoline and then reformulates by adding the purple dye.








_________________________
'04 Mazda RX8 5W30 Valv Synpwr
'10 &'11 Camry 5W-20 PU
'11 Landcruiser 5W20 PU
'13 BMW 550IX BMW 5W30
'08 BMW Z4M Coupe TWS 10W60
'13 BMW M6 BMW 5W30

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >