Recent Topics
New computer to buy?
by Eddie
10/01/14 11:08 AM
Oxygen Sensor Brand Dilemma
by 01_celica_gt
10/01/14 11:07 AM
Correct OEM Honda Part Number
by lancerplayer
10/01/14 10:14 AM
Sulfur Smell. Cat Issue?
by Miller88
10/01/14 08:49 AM
Destination LE/2
by Char Baby
10/01/14 07:49 AM
Rockauto sent me the wrong part
by Klutch9
10/01/14 07:30 AM
Sibling rivalry
by supton
10/01/14 07:26 AM
Recalls - our reward card saved us ($10)
by Shannow
10/01/14 06:40 AM
Drawbacks of high detergent oil?
by Spetz
10/01/14 06:24 AM
10/1-11/16 5 qt's Napa Synthetic w/Silver OF$21.99
by tenderloin
10/01/14 02:45 AM
10/1-10/28 O'Reilly Sales Ad
by tenderloin
10/01/14 02:15 AM
Got the Hi-Power
by john_pifer
10/01/14 12:03 AM
Newest Members
PAssatGuy, mcn1970, KCChemist, bbuice, Hemingway
51460 Registered Users
Who's Online
89 registered (440Magnum, 01_celica_gt, 147_Grain, adolan21, 123Saab, 8 invisible), 1766 Guests and 157 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Forum Stats
51460 Members
64 Forums
220071 Topics
3475125 Posts

Max Online: 2862 @ 07/07/14 03:10 PM
Donate to BITOG

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Topic Options
#3453321 - 08/12/14 10:36 AM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
kschachn Online   content


Registered: 12/26/05
Posts: 2603
Loc: Upper Midwest
I really can't believe this thread has turned into an argument about which oil filter is "best". Let's say I even believe that Wix/Napa Gold is better and Fram Ultra is best. What is that going to get me in terms of engine longevity as opposed to buying a Hengst filter at my dealer?

I can answer that right now. Zilch, nada, zippo.
_________________________
1994 BMW 530i, 189K
1996 Honda Accord, 203K
1999 Toyota Sienna, 304K
2000 Toyota ECHO, 224K

Top
#3453329 - 08/12/14 10:45 AM Re: BMW filter options [Re: kschachn]
d00df00d Offline


Registered: 10/20/05
Posts: 9191
Loc: PA
Originally Posted By: kschachn
But unlike the Japanese brands, you generally know who the OEM manufacturer is. In the majority of cases you can buy parts that are identical to branded OEM for less money, such as ATE, Lemforder, TRW, Bosch, Pagid, or whatever. Although for a lot of parts if you buy them from an online dealer the price differential isn't much.

Very true. That's why it's crucial to distinguish between OE (the actual part from the actual brand) and OEM (the "same part" from the company that makes it).

OEM parts are often exactly the same as OE, as you say.

You could also end up with a part that was made in the same batch but was outside the OE tolerances.

Either way, you probably won't get the OE warranty. That alone should tell you something.

On my old M3, my success rate with OEM parts was pretty high. My success rate with OE parts was 100%. Not a night-and-day difference, but significant IME.
_________________________
2011 Mazda RX-8 R3
Castrol GTX 5w-20

Top
#3453352 - 08/12/14 11:03 AM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
Dufus2 Offline


Registered: 12/12/13
Posts: 164
Loc: Virginia
This is a good question because I buy MANN, HENGST, MAHLE from Amazon for a decent price with a Prime membership. The WIX brand is also made in Poland for most European vehicles. I am not stating one is better than the other, only that these are not made in US facilities and are OEM quality. The Purolator I have on the shelf is made in India, and I have no interest in the one in an Orange Box.

The above mentioned filters fit a Mercedes diesel, BMW would be similar.
_________________________
ASE Certified in Med/Heavy Truck Service including A9
Heavy Equipment Repair, Fleet Maintenance
Real Cars Rattle and Smoke a Little

Top
#3453357 - 08/12/14 11:07 AM Re: BMW filter options [Re: Dufus2]
route66mike Offline


Registered: 07/09/14
Posts: 147
Loc: Ft. Collins
Originally Posted By: Dufus2
This is a good question because I buy MANN, HENGST, MAHLE from Amazon for a decent price with a Prime membership. The WIX brand is also made in Poland for most European vehicles. I am not stating one is better than the other, only that these are not made in US facilities and are OEM quality. The Purolator I have on the shelf is made in India, and I have no interest in the one in an Orange Box.

The above mentioned filters fit a Mercedes diesel, BMW would be similar.


I'd pick an oil filter based on how it performs, not on what hunch I have. I don't use divining rods to find water either. Lets keep it real. If it performs better, use it.

Peformance specs have been stated many times: Fram Ultra best, followed by Fram ToughGuards, Mobil 1 Extended, Purolator Synthetic, or Wix (napa gold same), and Carquest is really a Wix too.

Top
#3453367 - 08/12/14 11:14 AM Re: BMW filter options [Re: route66mike]
kschachn Online   content


Registered: 12/26/05
Posts: 2603
Loc: Upper Midwest
Originally Posted By: route66mike
[/quote]I'd pick an oil filter based on how it performs, not on what hunch I have. I don't use divining rods to find water either. Lets keep it real. If it performs better, use it.

Peformance specs have been stated many times: Fram Ultra best, followed by Fram ToughGuards, Mobil 1 Extended, Purolator Synthetic, or Wix (napa gold same), and Carquest is really a Wix too.


So if I buy a BMW/Hengst filter I'm contributing to excessive engine wear and the early demise of my '94? Gee, if I had only known.
_________________________
1994 BMW 530i, 189K
1996 Honda Accord, 203K
1999 Toyota Sienna, 304K
2000 Toyota ECHO, 224K

Top
#3453383 - 08/12/14 11:34 AM Re: BMW filter options [Re: route66mike]
srbarnes4ever Offline


Registered: 09/03/02
Posts: 21
Loc: Lexington, KY
Originally Posted By: route66mike
Originally Posted By: Dufus2
This is a good question because I buy MANN, HENGST, MAHLE from Amazon for a decent price with a Prime membership. The WIX brand is also made in Poland for most European vehicles. I am not stating one is better than the other, only that these are not made in US facilities and are OEM quality. The Purolator I have on the shelf is made in India, and I have no interest in the one in an Orange Box.

The above mentioned filters fit a Mercedes diesel, BMW would be similar.


I'd pick an oil filter based on how it performs, not on what hunch I have. I don't use divining rods to find water either. Lets keep it real. If it performs better, use it.

Peformance specs have been stated many times: Fram Ultra best, followed by Fram ToughGuards, Mobil 1 Extended, Purolator Synthetic, or Wix (napa gold same), and Carquest is really a Wix too.


Is this a comparison of AM brands only or are the OE BMW filters in this case even lower on the list? Thanks!
_________________________
Peace,
Stevie B.
07 335i
11 X5

Top
#3453411 - 08/12/14 12:00 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
Originally Posted By: srbarnes4ever
Originally Posted By: route66mike
I'd pick an oil filter based on how it performs, not on what hunch I have. I don't use divining rods to find water either. Lets keep it real. If it performs better, use it.

Peformance specs have been stated many times: Fram Ultra best, followed by Fram ToughGuards, Mobil 1 Extended, Purolator Synthetic, or Wix (napa gold same), and Carquest is really a Wix too.


Is this a comparison of AM brands only or are the OE BMW filters in this case even lower on the list? Thanks!


The German-made group of oil filters for BMWs (Hengst, Mann, Mahle) don't tell their filtration performance. Like its been said on these forums, and I tried to find out their performance myself and could not find anything, those German oil filters keep it all a trade secret.

For the performance enthusiast who wants something better, the German oil filter group is likely not the best to use. Your engine won't explode by using them. I like smaller particles filtered out of my oil. Each person needs to decide if they want MORE or LESS particles running around inside their engine.

If you want LESS particles, don't choose the German made oil filters. Why? >>>>> They only use wood-based cellulose fiber filter material in those brands. ... Fram Ultra, ToughGuard, ExtraGuards all put some or all synthetic glass fibers in their media for greater performance. Wix and the clones from napa and carquest also have glass in their media. This is how they get their higher performance scores.

Top
#3453415 - 08/12/14 12:04 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
SilverC6 Offline


Registered: 10/03/08
Posts: 1377
Loc: Southeast
Stay with the BMW OEM, Mahle, or German Mann oil filters for your BMW.

Amazon is one of the best sources to score these filters at a reduced cost.

Don't fall for the song from the FRAM fanboy sirens.

A FRAM has no place filtering oil in a BMW.

_________________________
'04 Mazda RX8 5W30 NAPA Syn
'10 &'11 Camry Edge 0W-20
'11 Landcruiser 5W20 PU
'13 BMW 550IX BMW 5W30
'08 BMW Z4M Coupe TWS 10W60
'13 BMW M6 BMW 5W30

Top
#3453424 - 08/12/14 12:14 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
Originally Posted By: srbarnes4ever

Is this a comparison of AM brands only or are the OE BMW filters in this case even lower on the list? Thanks!

Notice that SilverC6 doesn't have any facts or reasonable logic to support his Fram-hating stance. Actually, for BMWs, Wix/napagold are great choices, for better filtration efficiency, less particles in your oil. I'll back that up:

Top
#3453428 - 08/12/14 12:15 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
^^^ Mann (German made oil filter above) is using all-paper filter media, no glass fibers, yet is reasonably average for a filter, will work OK. Notice the pleat spacing, not bad, but you can do better. See my next post below.

Top
#3453431 - 08/12/14 12:17 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
Now lets look at the Wix-napagold-Carquest oil filter which was engineered for BETTER oil filtration:

Top
#3453434 - 08/12/14 12:19 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
Compare the two, the typical cellulose wood-chip-only oil filter for BMW (Mann), and then the Wix one that has more media surface area with glass fibers in there.

I like better filtration, so I pick the Wix.

Top
#3453442 - 08/12/14 12:22 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
Fram Ultra is a little harder to compare on just visuals alone, since it uses more of a depth filtration approach to get the best performance of any out there. All synthetic media does this.

Top
#3453448 - 08/12/14 12:28 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
The Mahle oil filter probably uses just paper cellulose, not sure, and they won't tell anybody their performance specs, but I'd use a Mahle over a Mann, choosing the best of the two bad choices anyway!

Mahle:


Edited by boundarylayer (08/12/14 12:35 PM)

Top
#3453454 - 08/12/14 12:30 PM Re: BMW filter options [Re: srbarnes4ever]
boundarylayer Offline


Registered: 06/29/14
Posts: 202
Loc: California
Hengst: Same comments as the Mahle. Here's a Hengst, at least it has plenty of surface area even if its probably on cellulose in there with unpublished performance specs:

Top
Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >