Okay, I resurrected a thread that died 02/20/13. However..................
I got one of these as a free gift for buying an OTC Hub Grappler. I too thought it was gimmicky. I also have access to scads of free nitrile gloves, so I never thought I would need this. Furthermore, I have a screened drain pan, so I thought, no worries.
It has been over a month since I have taken possession of my free gift and I have done 5 oil changes now. I must say I am pleased with this tool and would give it a thumbs up. If you have a European car with lots of plastic shrouding underneath, even better yet. It does reduce messes. Though I still wear my nitrile gloves.
Oh well............. Just my 2 cents.