I rode a pal's 1600 Road Star several hundred miles. I'm sure the new Road Star is a little better, but his '02 model was a total dog.
That engine was a real boat anchor. I was constantly bouncing it off the rev limiter trying to get decent thrust out of it, to no avail. Nasty bottom end vibration at about 80 mph. Hated it.
Not as good as a H-D TC 88 or 96 or a Victory 100. And nowhere near my favorite big v-twin, the 113 in the Raider or Roadliner . If you can afford it, go for one of the big Stars.
Ride comfort was OK, other than the high rpm vibration. Mediocre brakes and suspension. Typical cruiser in most ways. Handling wasn't terrible, in that it wasn't scary and the bike felt OK right up until the floorboards started dragging.