Originally Posted By: Chevys_n_Hawgs
What temp it "too high" when it comes to ATF?
Oxidation increases remarkably above 200F but it's time at temperature that counts for more than a spike. The longer the oil stays at that high temp, the faster it degrades. Most oils can take 250F easily... some even 300F... but their life gets drastically shortened the longer they remain at that temp.
There are spots in an automatic where the temp is momentarily very high while the bulk temp is fairly low. There can be a 100F difference in temp, or more, between the pan and the converter, for example.
Basically, if you were to monitor the pan temp and see 150-170, you'd be OK. If the pan is seeing 200 plus, imagine what the converter is seeing. Converter temp drops remarkably once the converter clutch locks (most modern transmissions have) so that tends to keep converter temp close to the pan temp. The converter is locked most of the time on the freeway
In town, with lots of starts and stops, not only are you running the converter unlocked a lot, you are cooking the trans oil every time it shifts. There is oil in the clutches and they slip a little every time the apply and with oil being in there, that oil is momentarily subjected to some high heat.
Also, at higher oil temps, synthetic base ATF oxidizes more slowly
So, as you can see, there is no one size fit's all answer. If you see regular temps under 200F, call it good. You should get good oil life. If you see regular temps higher, the OCI needs to be shorter.