Air cooled engine in cold weather ?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
799
Location
Michigan
I was over at one of my friends house and he showed me the new snow blade on his old JD mower. Looked nice, then I noticed that he had a piece of burlap taped over the air shroud intake...I said what the heck is that for ??? He told me that it restricted the air flow enough that his engine ran as warm in winter as it does in summer, better for the engine & oil.

Any thoughts on this ?
 
Here's my first thought -- your friend is crazy. Even when temperatures are very low, aircoolong needs to work.
 
Sound like an attempt at a make-shift thermostat.

Air cooled engines run at higher temperatures than liquid cooled engines. The additional cooling from winter conditions is likely a good thing. I wouldn't do anything to inhibit air flow through the engine fan. He should run a 5W30 oil in it for winter use and concentrate on warming the engine prior to starting if he concerned about getting the oil up to temperature. That's where most engine wear is caused on a well maintained engine.

Sack the sack and put a heater under the engine on real cold days.
 
Quote:
He told me that it restricted the air flow enough that his engine ran as warm in winter as it does in summer, better for the engine & oil

How is he verifying engine temp? Air cooled engines make plenty of heat even in cold weather, generally restricting air flow to them is not a good idea, excessive bore wear and even seizure is a possibility if they get to hot.
 
That's my thoughts also, this guy always comes up with crazy ideas. I have a heat lamp to warm mine up before use.

Thanks.
 
I agree this is a pretty ridiculous thing to do. How many millions of air-cooled snowblowers run just fine when it's 10 degrees out?
 
Originally Posted By: dparm
I agree this is a pretty ridiculous thing to do. How many millions of air-cooled snowblowers run just fine when it's 10 degrees out?


I said this to him, his reply was the snow blower was designed for cold weather and the mower was for hot summer.

I'll point him to this thread, Thanks
 
Hmm: I'm not so quick to condemn here. My old air cooled Porsche's & VWs restricted cooling air intake in colder weather. The issue here, is how much to restrict, so we really need a temp measurement on the cylinder to do it correctly.
 
Well you've just given him an out...haha

When he gets off work I'll ask him about temp monitoring, I didn't at the time because I was laughing and didn't want to get into a long drawn debate at the time.
 
My chainsaw came with a cold air kit too that restricts airflow but I don't use it even the odd time I cut in -20C.
I guess if it was -30C and I was cutting all the time I could see needing it, but you'd have to remember to take it off for a -10C day...
 
Air cooled motorcycles are fair weather machines but sitting in a traffic jam in hot weather isn't healthy for them either, they need air flow to cool the cylinders.
What about a VW beetle or Corvair? They ran in all seasons without restricting the air flow in cold weather.

I just looked at the ring end gap and piston skirt clearance and its the same on the snow engines as it is the lawn engines.
It appears the only real difference is the snow engine uses no air filter and the carb is shrouded to prevent icing by getting warmer air.
 
Originally Posted By: Trav
Air cooled motorcycles are fair weather machines but sitting in a traffic jam in hot weather isn't healthy for them either, they need air flow to cool the cylinders.
What about a VW beetle or Corvair? They ran in all seasons without restricting the air flow in cold weather.

I just looked at the ring end gap and piston skirt clearance and its the same on the snow engines as it is the lawn engines.
It appears the only real difference is the snow engine uses no air filter and the carb is shrouded to prevent icing by getting warmer air.


And since small engines are mass produced for various application I wouldn't think they change fin count on the fans so some would be for cold weather, but who knows maybe they do ???

[edit]= read Eddie's post about the VW
 
Last edited:
Quote:
My old air cooled Porsche's & VWs restricted cooling air intake in colder weather

IIRC this was more about carb icing then restricting air to the cylinders.
Many water cooled engines back in the day also had a summer/winter lever on the air intake housing.
 
I assume this old JD lawn/garden tractor has an 8 to 12hp Kohler K-series engine?

The K's do move a ton of air over the cylinder jug and you can really feel the heat pouring off of them in the summer.

Restricting them is not necessary. If your buddy has cold starting issues, he should use something along the lines of a synthetic 5w30.

Joel
 
I'm not so quick to say, "give an air cooled engine all the air it can handle regardless of temperature." Air cooled radial airplane engines have cowl flaps that can close to restrict air flow for a reason- to keep the engines warm enough so that piston clearances don't get huge and so that the oil continues to flow.

That said, radial airplane engines have temperature measurements (usually both cylinder head temp and oil temp) to control the cowl flaps and oil cooler doors. Snowblowers don't, so restricting the flow too much will certainly overheat them. But burlap is pretty open material, I doubt he's going to roast the engine with it.

What he's doing is certainly not necessary and probably not very helpful, but its not going to be deadly harmful either.

Story time... I spent a LOT of hours in my youth mowing with my Dad's old K181S powered 1966 JD tractor (which has quietly been sitting in his shed since he retired it in the late 90s and I would love to restore some day, but I digress...). Just a few minutes of mowing with the old Kohler K would result in a layer of grass clippings covering its fixed air intake screen. I would always scrape it off every so often, but it would still cake over with clippings regularly. That engine ran for ~15 years without a hiccup other than eventually turning into an oil burner, at which point we honed the cylinder and re-ringed it and it ran for another 10 years before he parked it (I was married with a kid by then- that was a TOUGH old iron-block engine!).
 
The Corvair has a completely shrouded engine with thermostatically controlled damper doors at the bottom. They really only came into use for warm up. Mine were always completely open after a few minutes of driving in any weather.
 
There's quite a bit of difference between an aircraft cruising at 180 mph or more in -40F temperatures and a lawn tractor working relatively hard pushing snow.

We're not breaking new ground here. Engines are designed to perform certain tasks. Engineers build in components/characteristics for them to perform and survive. I doubt very much that throwing a rag over the cooling air intake would be considered as being innovative engineering. Particularly when a seat of the pants thermometer is being used to measure engine temperatures.

Sack the sack.
 
FastGame, whatever you end up telling him, dont let this friend of yours join BITOG. This is an OCD-free forum, it doesnt need crazies like him polluting the place by second guessing the manufacturer with DIY shadetree re-engineering and stuff. No one here does that kind of thing.
lol.gif
 
Originally Posted By: boraticus
There's quite a bit of difference between an aircraft cruising at 180 mph or more in -40F temperatures and a lawn tractor working relatively hard pushing snow.

We're not breaking new ground here. Engines are designed to perform certain tasks. Engineers build in components/characteristics for them to perform and survive. I doubt very much that throwing a rag over the cooling air intake would be considered as being innovative engineering. Particularly when a seat of the pants thermometer is being used to measure engine temperatures.

Sack the sack.


Most air-cooled piston-powered airplanes don't fly high enough to be at -40C temps, those that do actually tend to have cooling issues due to the thinner air not carrying as much heat away.

Most air-cooled piston-powered airplanes also have a winter-kit that restricts cooling air and is used in colder locations during the winter.
 
Originally Posted By: quint
FastGame, whatever you end up telling him, dont let this friend of yours join BITOG. This is an OCD-free forum, it doesnt need crazies like him polluting the place by second guessing the manufacturer with DIY shadetree re-engineering and stuff. No one here does that kind of thing.
lol.gif



oh lord that one got me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top