Here is a very interesting systematic UOA comparison of Valvoline Premium Blue, Delo LE, Mobil Delvac 1300 Super, and Rotella 15W-40 oils:
Valvoline Blue, Chevron Delo, Mobil Delvac, and Shell Rotella UOA comparison
Delvac seems to be the winner; although Delo and Rotella seem to be very close. Valvoline Blue seems to be a little further behind.
Note that Shell Rotella and Valvoline Blue have virtually no friction modifiers (molybdenum and boron) and for this reason I wouldn't put these two oils in my engine myself. Some amount of friction modifiers is necessary to improve the effectiveness of ZDDP (because they decrease the force on the wear surfaces, on which ZDDP gets attached).
Delo has the most friction modifiers (some more molybdenum and a lot more boron); although, this doesn't necessarily translate into better wear protection, as there is an optimum level to increase the effectiveness of ZDDP and beyond that friction modifiers might actually decrease the effectiveness of ZDDP by getting in the way.
Delvac is the clear winner in viscosity retention. Rotella is the second best, and Delo and Blue fell behind significantly in viscosity retention. In my engine viscosity retention is important as I have high mileage (increased oil consumption); therefore, this eliminates Delo and Blue for me as well.
So, for my purposes, Mobil Delvac is the winner in all respects, as Shell Rotella and Valvoline Blue have no friction modifiers (therefore have questionable wear protection) and Chevron Delo and Valvoline Blue don't nearly match the viscosity retention of Mobil Delvac.