Another vote for the Motorcraft OEM pcv. I only use Genuine Toyota in my tacoma and Camry. They are the all metal type. I do mine about every 60K. In some cars aftermarket pcv's are ok but I have noticed this is not the case in fords and Toyotas thus far. If I go aftermaket in someone elses car, I usually go for Purolator. They seem to be decent.