What stops better on ice, wide or narrow tires?

Status
Not open for further replies.
The article that I posted kind of concluded "Thus, under identical load and on the same dry surface, the wider tire has a greater contact area and develops higher traction, resulting in greater stopping ability.", which is speaking to something different than contact patch varying with load.

The contact patch often doesn't vary that much with load, which is why tire size matters a lot once one is hitting some limits of traction. Note that depending upon the conditions one meay want wider tires for better traction in dry conditions or when one needs to 'float' on surfaces like sand, mud, etc. or narrower tires for higher load per contact patch such as for water covered surfaces or on winter tires.
 
That's exactly right. The idea of friction as a simple coefficient is wrong - and if it was right, it wouldn't matter what size the tires were. Friction between the surface and the tire can vary in very complex ways, so there are not necessarily easy answers for any question. However, wider tires being better on dry pavement and narrower tires being better on snow are usually safe bets.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top