I have them on my 1996 toyota tercel that takes 13 inch tires so it is not a great comparison. The are excellent in wet and dry..decent in snow although did slide some in snow two years ago...I eneded up getting michelin xice tires for winter on tercel...mainly cause tires for 13 in are so cheap 37 dollars...The vredestein tires are likely better than most all seasons for snow, but I would get snow tires for winter...especially if have real wheel drive car in minneapolis.