Many parts of the country, ethanol is REQUIRED by the EPA mandated "Oxygenated" gasoline program to reduce polution.
Early in the program, some gasoline used MBTE, while others used ethanol.
MBTE was later banned from most....maybe all (I'm careful about the term "always").
So, as you experienced in Illinois, many of us have no choice.
You will likely see a slight decrease in fuel economy, as ethanol has a lower energy content per volume (BTU).
However, many miles of driving on the "reformulated" fuel has not been an issue for me.
As modern vehicles are so well controlled with sensors and computers to adjust the air/fuel ratio to real time measurements, the change in the charactoristics of the fuel with ethanol versus the next tank of fuel without, etc, should be no issue.....as it will be well within the adaptive range of the vehicle's fuel system.
However, I can understand, those who live in the areas that do not require ethanol in the gasoline may do a double take when they see a "contains up to 10% ethanal" label on the fuel pump.